A notable preseason projection from John Machota of The Athletic places Schoonmaker fifth on a list of Cowboys players who need to elevate their game the most this season. The rationale is straightforward: the team invested a second-round pick in Schoonmaker in 2023, and last year he started only 13 games, recorded 14 receptions, and contributed modest yardage. In the pecking order at tight end, Jake Ferguson is the clear No. 1, with Brevin Spann-Ford moving into the No. 2 role. Schoonmaker’s development thus becomes critical as he eyes a meaningful role in a potential playoff-contending offense.
Last season’s numbers reinforce the sentiment. Schoonmaker started seven games and appeared in all 17, but finished with only 132 receiving yards, zero touchdowns, and seven first downs. He logged roughly 391 offensive snaps, which does not scream breakout potential or a franchise cornerstone. Given those statistics, analysts and fans alike are watching closely to see if he can translate opportunities into consistent production.
There is some optimism around Schoonmaker’s potential. In limited targets, he did average 6.1 yards after the catch per reception, indicating after-the-catch ability when the ball is in his hands. However, a lack of extensive playing time and a lack of touchdowns keep him from showcasing a comprehensive impact on the field. Additionally, he hasn’t yet earned a formal grading from some advanced metrics outlets, which adds to the perception that he still has a long way to go to prove himself as a reliable starting option.
Entering the final year of his rookie deal, Schoonmaker has a narrow window to demonstrate that he can contribute meaningfully in an offense that aspires to playoff success. The team’s approach last season was effective even with limited involvement from him, and a strong camp approach could provide a compelling reason to continue giving him opportunities. Conversely, if he struggles to stand out, the depth chart at tight end—featuring Ferguson and Spann-Ford—could lead to diminished opportunities and potentially accelerate a departure from the active roster.
Dak Prescott has emphasized the mindset needed for Schoonmaker to seize a more prominent role. He highlighted the importance of showing up with energy, securing every catch thrown his way, and delivering a physical block to complement the tight end’s role in the offense. The quarterback stressed that consistency and readiness on Sundays are essential for increasing his chances of remaining a key contributor.
From a strategic standpoint, Schoonmaker’s best path to securing a lasting role involves converting opportunities into consistent production, showing reliable blocking, and developing a stronger rapport with the quarterback and the offense. If he can translate his athletic traits into tangible gains—such as more receptions, more yards after catch, and occasional red-zone contributions—the Cowboys would have a stronger case to keep him firmly in the mix.
On the other hand, if Schoonmaker’s training camp performance does not demonstrate clear improvement, the Cowboys could opt to rely more heavily on Ferguson and Spann-Ford, with Schoonmaker serving as a depth option or a practice squad consideration. The 2024 and 2025 seasons have shown that the tight end group can be productive when all pieces harmonize, and Schoonmaker’s development remains a factor in how potent this offense can be in the coming year.
In sum, Schoonmaker faces a pivotal year. The coaching staff and front office will be evaluating his progress closely during camp, looking for him to demonstrate improved route running, dependable hands, and a willingness to contribute in the running game. If he can deliver a big season in his final rookie year, the Cowboys gain a valuable weapon and a compelling depth asset. If not, the tight end depth chart could shift as the team prioritizes proven production in a playoff-driven offense.
