Wake Forest delivered a commanding performance at Gerald J. Ford Stadium, overwhelming SMU from the opening drive and building a 28-0 lead before the Mustangs could find their footing. The Demon Deacons continued to pull away, taking a stunning 42-0 advantage into halftime on their way to a 49-7 victory.
The result prompted prominent college football commentators Kirk Herbstreit, Pat McAfee and Scott Van Pelt to publicly acknowledge that they had underestimated Wake Forest.
Herbstreit, speaking in a video with McAfee, said the two wanted to apologize for picking against the Demon Deacons. They had believed SMU could take advantage of playing at home, he explained, but admitted they were wrong and praised Wake Forest as a legitimate team.
McAfee echoed the apology, taking responsibility for their prediction. Van Pelt also addressed his pick, saying he had been familiar with Wake Forest but had chosen SMU anyway. He described the Demon Deacons as an exceptionally strong team.
Their comments reflected a broader change in the conversation around Wake Forest. The team had put together an impressive season in the ACC, but national attention had not always matched its results. The decisive win in Dallas made it much harder to dismiss the Demon Deacons as merely a solid conference team.
Wake Forest finished with 475 total yards and controlled the game on both sides of the ball. SMU managed just one touchdown and struggled to recover from the early deficit. Turnovers and special-teams mistakes added to the Mustangs’ problems, helping Wake Forest establish a lead that proved insurmountable before the third quarter began.
The victory was not an isolated surprise. Under head coach Jake Dickert, Wake Forest entered the game with an 8-1 overall record and a 5-1 mark in ACC play. The Demon Deacons had been ranked as high as No. 13 in the College Football Playoff rankings.
Their only loss had come against Miami earlier in the season. Since then, Wake Forest had recorded several dominant results, including a 51-7 win over Virginia and a 77-0 victory against Merrimack.
Quarterback Gio Lopez has helped drive the team’s success, giving the offense a balance between passing and an effective ground game. Wake Forest’s defense has also played a major role, limiting opponents and creating opportunities for the offense to work with short fields.
Despite that record, SMU entered the matchup as the betting favorite in some circles, and several well-known analysts had backed the Mustangs. The perception of Wake Forest as a capable but not elite ACC program persisted even as the team kept winning. Its performance against SMU challenged that view in emphatic fashion.
The Demon Deacons did more than secure a road victory. They dismantled a team considered a serious threat in the ACC title race and a possible contender for playoff consideration. The apologies from Herbstreit, McAfee and Van Pelt were notable in part because of their broad audiences. Their change of tone helped signal that Wake Forest’s results were gaining wider recognition.
For SMU, the defeat had significant consequences. The Mustangs fell to 7-3, and their chances of reaching the ACC Championship Game were effectively closed on their home field. Kevin Jennings and the offense could not find a rhythm against a Wake Forest defense that had been among the league’s more consistent units.
The larger lesson reaches beyond this single game. In college football, prominent programs and conference reputations can shape expectations, but strong results can eventually force a reassessment. Wake Forest had spent much of the season making its case through its play. A 42-0 halftime lead against SMU left little room for doubt about the scale of the team’s performance.
As the regular season winds down, Wake Forest is scheduled to travel to face Georgia Tech before closing at home against Duke. After the victory over SMU, the Demon Deacons stood at 9-1 and carried momentum into the final stretch. Their performance in Dallas gave them a more prominent national narrative—and offered a clear reminder that they should not be overlooked.