Patrick O’Neill’s career took him from college football to the NFL and then into medicine. Now 55, the former New England Patriots punter is suing the NCAA, alleging that it failed to protect him from head injuries during his college football career. The lawsuit follows his diagnosis with Parkinson’s disease.
O’Neill and his wife, Robin Wulling, filed the complaint in Manhattan Supreme Court on November 2. He alleges that he was encouraged to continue playing after head injuries without being informed about the risks.
The lawsuit argues that the NCAA failed to make college football as safe as possible and did not provide O’Neill with the information he needed to make informed decisions about playing and protecting his health. It also claims that he was repeatedly exposed to head trauma during games and practices, despite medical recommendations that players be kept out of contact sports after three moderate concussions.
According to the complaint, O’Neill was not removed from the field for examination, rest or treatment after sustaining head trauma. The lawsuit further states that Parkinson’s has caused significant losses, including affecting his ability to work as an orthopedic surgeon.
## A standout career at Syracuse
Before becoming a doctor, O’Neill made his mark as a punter and kicker at Syracuse University. He was named the 1992 Big East Special Teams Player of the Year and finished his college career with an average of 41.1 yards per punt, the second-best mark in school history. One of his punts traveled 72 yards against Maryland, making it the second-longest in Syracuse history.
His achievements extended beyond the field. O’Neill was an Academic All-American and a University Scholar, Syracuse’s highest academic honor, and earned a degree in bioengineering.
The New England Patriots selected him in the fifth round of the NFL draft. In his first professional season, he was named the league’s All-Rookie punter. His NFL career lasted only a few years, and he eventually turned toward medicine.
O’Neill enrolled at Johns Hopkins University in 1998. He later completed a five-year surgical residency at the University of Maryland Shock Trauma Center and Union Memorial Hospital.
In reflecting on his decision to leave football, O’Neill said he considered whether he wanted to devote his life to the sport, even if he had played for many more years. He concluded that he wanted to attend medical school and that football was not his strongest long-term interest.
## From soccer to professional football
O’Neill did not grow up particularly interested in football. He played soccer, but people who noticed his kicking ability encouraged him to try the more physical sport. He had initially hoped to attend an Ivy League school.
His kicking skills also attracted the attention of legendary coach Bill Parcells, helping put him on the path to the NFL.
O’Neill’s Parkinson’s diagnosis has added to broader concern about possible long-term effects of repeated head impacts in football. A Harvard study found that at least one in four former NFL players who died between 2016 and 2021 had chronic traumatic encephalopathy, or CTE. CTE is a neurodegenerative disease associated with repeated head impacts, though an individual diagnosis does not, by itself, establish the cause of a person’s condition.
O’Neill’s lawsuit contends that his Parkinson’s developed as a result of his football experience. That connection will be central to the case, but it remains an allegation rather than a legal finding.
## Challenges in earlier NCAA cases
O’Neill is not the first former football player to sue the NCAA over head injuries. More than 300 lawsuits had been filed by former players by 2019, involving complaints such as headaches and depression. Some cases also involved early-onset Parkinson’s or Alzheimer’s disease.
In 2014, the NCAA reached a settlement that provided $70 million for concussion testing and diagnosis for current and former NCAA athletes. The settlement resolved several claims, but it did not mean that every future lawsuit involving head injuries would succeed.
A 2022 case illustrates the legal difficulty. Attorneys sought $55 million for the widow of Matthew Gee, a former USC linebacker who suffered permanent brain damage and died at age 49. The jury found the NCAA not liable.
That outcome highlights a central challenge for plaintiffs: showing not only that an injury occurred, but also that the NCAA or another defendant had a legal duty to protect the player, breached that duty and caused the resulting harm.
Gabe Feldman, director of Tulane University’s sports law program, has described these cases as difficult because proving causation can be especially challenging. A plaintiff may have suffered serious harm, but establishing that a particular organization’s conduct legally caused it requires evidence addressing each part of the claim.
O’Neill’s case will face that same test. The lawsuit raises questions about what the NCAA knew, what protections were in place during his college career and whether his alleged head injuries can be legally connected to his Parkinson’s diagnosis. Until those issues are resolved, the claims remain allegations before the court.