Context and expectations
Entering 2026, one of the biggest talking points around the Broncos was the decision to shift play-calling responsibilities away from Payton, who has extensive experience as both a head coach and a primary play-caller, into the hands of Webb. Webb has not previously served as a full-time NFL play-caller, and the experience gap compared with Payton’s decade-spanning résumé raised the ceiling and floor questions for the offense. The anticipation was that Webb would implement a fresh approach while Payton would remain closely involved in game planning and critical decision-making.
Week 1 performance and what it signals
Against a high-caliber opponent in the Chiefs, the Broncos’ offensive showing drew cautious concern. Early in the game, the offense appeared out of sync, and the execution on critical downs did not meet expectations. The performance highlighted how difficult it is to establish a cohesive, high-functioning attack when the primary play-caller is adapting to a new role, even with a seasoned head coach providing guidance.
From a numbers perspective, the offense faced several challenges. Analytics and advanced metrics painted a rough picture of the unit’s efficiency. EPA (expected points added) per play was notably negative, reflecting limited efficiency on crucial possessions. The success rate on plays was also lacking, particularly in the passing game. Quarterback play—while facing tough competition—produced subpar efficiency in attempts and completion consistency, contributing to a low overall success rate for the aerial assault.
The rushing attack did not fare much better. Negative EPA per rush and a modest success rate indicated that the ground game struggled to consistently gain ground and sustain drives. In a matchup where balanced production is often the key to sustaining offensive pressure, these early indicators suggested that the Broncos needed to refine both the game plan and execution to avoid piling up negative plays and unfavorable down-and-distance situations.
The mental and strategic aspects
One notable takeaway from Payton’s remarks after the game was his emphasis on process and preparation, rather than assigning blame for the play-calling arrangement. He acknowledged that, regardless of who is calling plays, the feel of the game can be frustrating and that the experience and discipline required to execute at a high level remains paramount.
The takeaway for the coaching staff is clear: while the play-caller role is important, the ultimate measure is how the offense responds, adjusts, and executes during live sequences. Even with Payton providing direct input and oversight, the Broncos must translate planned concepts into efficient, adaptable in-game responses.
Looking ahead: opportunities and potential adjustments
The Broncos have 17 more games to refine their approach. The transition period, while demanding, also offers a chance to tailor the offense to Webb’s strengths and the personnel’s skill sets. Here are a few focal points that could help the unit improve as the season progresses:
– Play design and timing: Emphasize concepts that simplify reads for the quarterback and reduce the likelihood of negative plays. Incorporate quick throws, efficient play-action, and rhythm passes to help the offense establish a tempo that can carry through the game.
– In-game adjustments: Develop a robust framework for mid-game adjustments, with clear decision trees for personnel groupings, down-and-distance scenarios, and situational play-calling. This can mitigate the learning curve that comes with a new play-caller.
– Personnel utilization: Leverage the strengths of the skill players through matchup-based calls and tailored route concepts. Ensuring players are put into positions where they can maximize yards after catch and efficiency can elevate the offense even if the play-caller is still bedding in.
– Protection and scheme: Strong pass protection and well-timed run-pass options can help the quarterback execute with confidence. A balanced attack that keeps defenses honest is essential for sustaining drives and building rhythm.
Coach and player mindset
Communication between Payton and Webb will be critical. A collaborative approach that blends Payton’s wealth of experience with Webb’s fresh perspective can yield a dynamic offensive identity. The coaching staff can use early-season film and practice reps to reinforce what works and discard what doesn’t, ensuring the offense evolves rather than stalls.
Conclusion
The Week 1 performance underscored the growing pains inherent in transitioning to a new play-caller, especially one new to the role at the NFL level. It also highlighted the underlying potential within the Broncos’ personnel. With 17 weeks left in the season, there is ample time to implement adjustments, build coherence, and develop a more effective, resilient offensive identity. The key will be disciplined execution, thoughtful play design, and timely in-game adjustments to maximize the capabilities of the roster and align with Payton’s overarching vision for the team. The season remains wide open, and if the coaching staff and players commit to steady improvement, the Broncos can still chart a successful course in 2026.
