As the 2026 NFL Draft approaches, the quarterback class is viewed as thin beyond Fernando Mendoza and possibly Ty Simpson, raising the stakes for teams in need of a signal-caller to consider McCarthy as a trade option.
Chip Scoggins of The Minnesota Star Tribune weighed in on whether a McCarthy deal could happen before or at the draft, noting that there are still people who believe a trade is possible but expressing skepticism about its likelihood.
“There are still people who think [a McCarthy trade] is a possibility,” Scoggins said, but he added he doesn’t see it happening. He suggested the Wentz signing has fueled talk about moving McCarthy, yet he stands by his read of the situation: moving McCarthy would imply admitting they misjudged his evaluation and development.
McCarthy is receiving encouragement from former Vikings wideout Adam Thielen, who praised his mindset and competitive edge. Thielen described McCarthy as a creator who carries a strong, winning mentality, noting that being around him gives a clear sense of his determination.
Thielen also emphasized that McCarthy knows what he must improve to become a starter, pointing to the challenges of being a high draft pick who dealt with injuries early in his career and missed valuable development time while on injured reserve.
With the Vikings aiming to avoid missing the playoffs in 2026, the Week 1 starter debate remains tied to the ongoing competition and the evolving landscape of the 2026 QB class, potentially shaping any near-term moves or discussions around J.J. McCarthy.
