Analysts are divided on that approach. NFL veteran Adam Schein argues against using a first-round pick on a quarterback, saying Simpson isn’t the answer and suggesting Will Howard could be a better NFL option, even if not a clear starter. He also notes the team could benefit more from bolstering the line or the defense rather than investing early in a QB.
Conversely, a CBS Sports draft analyst says the Steelers do like Simpson and could target him at 21, or even trade back into the first to secure him. Pittsburgh reportedly has the flexibility to move Day 2 selections to climb back into the back end of the first, should Simpson still be on the board.
The Steelers’ quarterback situation is further complicated by Aaron Rodgers’ status. With Rodgers’ future undecided, Pittsburgh remains in wait-and-see mode, balancing the potential need to plan for a long-term option behind Rodgers with the current roster-building timeline.
Simpson’s college production provides a compelling profile: he threw for 3,567 yards and 28 touchdowns against five interceptions last season. As the Steelers evaluate their options, differing expert opinions could influence how aggressively they pursue a quarterback at the top of the 2026 draft.
