The Jets’ line is largely defined, with Armand Membou and Olu Fashanu as bookend tackles, Joe Tippman at guard, and Josh Myers re-signed at center. Simpson’s status stands out as the only open spot on the starting group, making his future with the team a major talking point.
SNY’s Lucas Hutcherson urged the Jets to re-sign Simpson, emphasizing his durability. He noted that the 2025 line stayed healthy all season, with five Week 1 starters under contract for 2026, so locking Simpson would help maintain continuity and cohesion.
However, concerns over penalties and a potential decline in play complicate the decision. Simpson had a team-high 10 penalties in 2025 and seven in 2024, prompting questions about on-field discipline. The Jets could view a cost-cutting upgrade or a less penalized option as appealing.
An in-house alternative to consider is Alijah Vera-Tucker, the former 14th overall pick who has shown Pro Bowl upside when healthy but has struggled to stay on the field. Vera-Tucker has appeared in only 43 of 85 games, so availability remains the critical factor.
There has been reported interest in re-signing Vera-Tucker, with ESPN’s Rich Cimini noting the Jets’ interest in bringing him back on a potential one-year prove-it deal. That approach could balance upside with durability while the team evaluates other options in free agency and the draft.
Ultimately, the Jets’ decision at left guard will shape their 2026 lineup. Re-signing Simpson would provide continuity and reliability; pursuing Vera-Tucker or other avenues could offer higher upside if health cooperates, all while navigating cost and long-term value.
