Chelsea’s 4-1 defeat to Leeds United at Stamford Bridge has intensified frustration among supporters. It followed another disappointing home result last month, when the Blues lost to Tottenham Hotspur. During the Leeds match, some fans turned their anger towards manager Xabi Alonso, with chants questioning his approach.
The result has also reignited debate over Chelsea’s formation. Alonso may consider returning to a back three, a system he used earlier in the season. The change could appeal to some supporters, though it may mean fewer minutes for Estevao Willian.
## Chelsea’s back three versus back four
Chelsea began the season using a back three or back five. Alonso’s 3-4-2-1 formation left room for three attackers, with Cole Palmer, Morgan Rogers and Joao Pedro occupying those positions while all three were in strong form. Some fans felt the system limited Estevao’s opportunities.
Alonso later switched to a back four, and Chelsea recorded some positive results in that shape, including a 2-0 away win over Everton. The change also created more opportunities for Estevao. However, one supporter argued after the Leeds defeat that Chelsea had looked better with three centre-backs and had players suited to that system, including new signings Pep Chavarria and Marco Palestra.
Chelsea have used a back three in six Premier League matches this season, winning three and losing three. In five matches with a back four, they have won two, drawn one and lost two. The figures are based on a limited sample, but they offer a useful comparison:
| Formation | Games | Wins | Losses | Draws | Win rate | Goals scored | Goals per game | Goals conceded | Goals conceded per game |
|—|—:|—:|—:|—:|—:|—:|—:|—:|—:|
| Back three | 6 | 3 | 3 | 0 | 50% | 13 | 2.17 | 13 | 2.17 |
| Back four | 5 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 40% | 7 | 1.4 | 7 | 1.4 |
The numbers do not point to an automatic solution. Chelsea have conceded more goals per game in a back three, but they have also scored more often and recorded a higher win rate in that formation. With only 11 matches in total, the comparison should be treated with caution.
## Why Alonso changed the formation
The 3-4-2-1 was Alonso’s preferred system at Bayer Leverkusen, and he used it during pre-season and at the start of his Chelsea campaign. But he faced pressure from supporters and the media to give Estevao more playing time, which was harder to do with three attacking places occupied by Palmer, Rogers and Pedro. Injuries have also limited Alonso’s ability to use a back three.
Chelsea are currently without Maxence Lacroix, who had been playing as the central centre-back in that system. His absence has added to the challenges of setting up with three central defenders.
## Could a back three suit Chelsea better?
A back three can become a back five when the wing-backs drop back to defend, potentially making a team more compact. Chelsea’s defensive problems, however, may have as much to do with the performances of their centre-backs as with the formation itself.
Levi Colwill and Wesley Fofana have not been in form this season. If they are central to the defence, Chelsea may continue to concede goals regardless of the system. The team’s defensive personnel therefore remain a key consideration in any tactical change.
Alonso could still decide that a back three better suits his approach. Chelsea have scored at a higher rate and won a greater share of their matches in that formation, while the manager has a clear preference for it. Improving the quality and depth of the centre-back group could also help the system work more effectively.
Chelsea may need to add another centre-back or two to give Alonso more options. The club has been linked with Alessandro Bastoni, and a three-man defence built around a player of his profile could allow Palmer, Pedro and Rogers to form the attacking trio. That approach could reduce Estevao’s minutes, but the available results suggest the back three remains a formation worth considering.