Manchester United reportedly spent more than £150 million on midfield additions Andrey Santos, Youri Tielemans and Carlos Baleba during the summer transfer window. So far, the new signings have not helped turn results around, and the team sits in the Premier League relegation zone.
A week after Michael Carrick’s dismissal, chief executive Omar Berrada gave his first interview in 18 months and said the club had “made progress” in improving the squad. But there is a meaningful difference between adding players and resolving the problems that already exist. The league table offers little evidence that United’s recruitment has yet delivered the results supporters want.
## United’s hierarchy and its supporters measure success differently
Berrada has expressed satisfaction with the club’s transfer business, but supporters have reason to question whether the hierarchy sees the squad as they do. United lack experienced cover for Luke Shaw at left-back, as well as a reserve centre-forward to step in while Joshua Zirkzee is injured.
His comments have also raised concerns about how well the hierarchy understands supporters’ views. Berrada said most fans favour a new stadium, overlooking calls from match-going supporters to abandon the proposal.
United have also dismissed three permanent managers over the previous three campaigns, with Ineos executives Jim Ratcliffe, Berrada and Jason Wilcox playing key roles in each decision. The club has spent more than £100 million on managerial dismissals since David Moyes was sacked in 2014.
Recruitment has been another persistent problem. United have missed out on players such as Erling Haaland and Jude Bellingham, while signing Rasmus Hojlund and Christian Eriksen, who was past his best. These decisions have contributed to doubts about the club’s ability to build a squad capable of sustained success.
Financial prudence and a lack of ambition are not the same thing. However, Berrada and his colleagues can be criticised for appearing to place revenue ahead of on-field results, particularly after Avram Glazer acknowledged that the club continues to make money even when it fails on the pitch.
The divide between how supporters and the hierarchy define progress is a serious concern. If commercial growth takes priority over sporting success, statements about improving the squad are unlikely to reassure fans without a corresponding improvement on the pitch.