Week 11 of the NFL regular season began with a difficult night for the Indianapolis Colts. The Houston Texans defeated them 26–3 on Thursday Night Football, while Indianapolis struggled to generate offense. As the score grew increasingly lopsided, fans turned to social media to share their reactions—and to find something to talk about beyond the game itself.
Colts owner Carlie Irsay-Gordon became a prominent subject of the online jokes. Viewers focused on her activity along the sideline, where she was seen pacing and writing in a notebook. With the Colts trailing and unable to mount a meaningful response, posts about her notes quickly became part of the evening’s running commentary.
Some users joked that her notebook contained the words “WE SUCK!” Others offered imagined “exclusive” looks at what she might be writing or made light of the team’s performance with claims that the Colts might be banned. The posts were playful speculation, not actual descriptions of the notebook’s contents.
The attention followed previous criticism of Irsay-Gordon’s sideline presence. Her note-taking and movement during games have drawn commentary from sports media figures, including former ESPN personality Ryen Russillo and Bill Simmons. Their remarks reflected a broader debate about how an NFL owner’s conduct on the sideline is perceived by viewers.
Irsay-Gordon has explained that she takes notes because she wants to learn more about football, including how coaching decisions are made and how a team operates. In an interview, she described how her interest in learning more grew after the Colts hired Chuck Pagano in 2012.
She said being on the headset helped her understand the complexity of a football team and the many people involved in each play. A mistake that appears to come from a player, she explained, could instead result from a communication or play-calling error. Understanding those distinctions, she said, can help the organization determine where it needs to make changes, provide resources or correct problems.
Irsay-Gordon also said that learning more about the team’s operations could help those responsible for making decisions about coaches and general managers. In her view, gaining a better understanding of how the organization functions may help reduce the chance of making costly mistakes.
The online reaction during the Texans game was shaped by the Colts’ performance. With Indianapolis producing little offense in the 26–3 defeat, fans looked for other details to discuss. Irsay-Gordon’s visible sideline presence gave them an easy focus, and jokes about her notebook spread as the game continued to get away from the Colts.
Whether that scrutiny is fair is another question. Owners are often visible at games, and their presence can draw attention when a team is struggling. But the same sideline behavior might receive less notice if the team were playing well. On a night when the Colts’ offense failed to provide much entertainment, Irsay-Gordon’s pacing and note-taking became part of the conversation.
The reaction underscored how quickly social media can shift its focus during a lopsided game. Rather than concentrating only on the score, fans joked about what might be written in a notebook and used the owner’s sideline activity as a way to express their frustration with the team’s performance. For Irsay-Gordon, that meant becoming the center of a roast session during a particularly rough night for Indianapolis.