At 7–6, the New York Knicks have made a slow start to their title defense. Several issues have contributed, including an uneven offense marked by poor shooting, too many turnovers and reduced production in clutch situations. Roster construction is another concern, particularly for a team that began the season relatively healthy after winning a championship.
The Knicks have a crowded group of guards. Landry Shamet, Miles McBride, Tyler Kolek, Jordan Clarkson and Jose Alvarado have each shown value when given opportunities, while higher-paid players Mikal Bridges and Josh Hart have struggled to make the same impact so far. New York also moved on from Mitchell Robinson, leaving the team with a need to strengthen its options among the big men.
That imbalance makes a trade a possible solution. The Knicks have several guards to consider moving, while adding frontcourt help could address a roster need. A deal that combines multiple players or assets for a more impactful piece is often described as a consolidation trade.
## Why a Consolidation Trade Could Appeal to New York
The Knicks have made significant changes through trades before. In the 2023–24 season, they sent Immanuel Quickley and RJ Barrett to acquire OG Anunoby. They later moved Evan Fournier and Quentin Grimes, two players who were unhappy with their roles and playing time.
A similar approach could help New York simplify its roster, although finding the right deal would be complicated. McBride is one potential trade candidate because he is on an expiring contract. His salary is about $4 million, however, which could make it difficult for the Knicks to match salaries for a player capable of helping the team compete for another championship.
Bridges presents a different possibility. He is beginning a four-year, $150 million extension, so moving him could reduce the team’s long-term salary commitments. It could also create more room under the NBA’s second apron, which affects a team’s roster-building flexibility. Karl-Anthony Towns and Hart are both eligible for extensions, but extension discussions were halted amid owner James Dolan’s directive concerning the second apron.
Hart’s contract adds another consideration. He is eligible for an extension, but his deal includes a $22 million team option for next season. Any decision about his future would need to account for both his role on the court and the team’s financial planning.
## The Challenges of Making a Deal
Identifying players who might be moved is easier than finding a trade that works for everyone involved. Other teams may be reluctant to take on Bridges’ contract, which runs for several years and carries a total value of $150 million. That could limit the Knicks’ options if they decide that moving him is necessary to create financial flexibility.
Trading Hart would also carry a potential cost beyond his production. His presence is part of the team’s chemistry, so losing him could affect the group’s cohesion. The Knicks would have to weigh that risk against the value of any player or financial flexibility they received in return.
McBride may be easier to discuss as a trade candidate because of his expiring deal, but his relatively low salary creates a matching challenge. A player earning about $4 million may not be enough, by himself, to bring back the kind of established contributor New York needs. The Knicks could have to include additional pieces or structure a more complex transaction.
The need for frontcourt depth is not new. New York looked for backup big men throughout the summer but did not complete a deal. That search reflects the difficulty of finding a suitable player at the right price, and the same obstacles would apply during the season.
A consolidation trade is therefore a reasonable idea, not a simple fix. The Knicks have a surplus of guards and a need for more help among their big men, but salary matching, contract length, team chemistry and the second apron all complicate the decision. Leon Rose and the front office may need to explore several possibilities before finding a move that improves the roster without creating new problems. At a minimum, the team’s early struggles give New York reason to keep looking for a way to make its roster more balanced.