New York Giants head coach John Harbaugh is facing criticism for choosing rookie kicker Dominic Zvada over veteran Jason Sanders. Sanders has since joined the New York Jets and delivered a strong performance at MetLife Stadium, while Zvada continues to struggle with consistency.
Sanders made all four of his field-goal attempts in the Jets’ 31–12 Week 10 loss to the Buffalo Bills. His performance renewed questions about the Giants’ decision, particularly because Sanders has been productive at the same stadium where Zvada has had difficulties. Podcast host Dan Schneier noted that Sanders had made 21 of 24 field goals that season, with all three misses coming from at least 50 yards. He had been perfect on attempts shorter than 50 yards and on extra points.
SNY reporter Connor Hughes also pointed out that the Giants had concerns about whether Sanders’ kicking style would work at MetLife Stadium. Sanders had spent his first eight NFL seasons with the Miami Dolphins, giving him regular experience kicking there as a division rival.
## Dominic Zvada’s Right-Hashmark Struggles
Zvada has missed six field goals, all from the right hashmark. One of those misses came in the Giants’ Week 10 game against the Washington Commanders. Former Giants kicker Lawrence Tynes, a two-time Super Bowl champion, suggested that inconsistent alignment may be contributing to the problem.
Tynes explained that right-footed kickers can struggle from the right hash when they try to steer the ball toward the left. Instead, he said, kickers should rely on a consistent alignment and make a natural swing through the ball. He added that Zvada’s misses in both directions may reflect variations in how close or far away he is from the ball at contact.
Although Tynes believes the issue can be corrected with practice and game experience, he also urged patience. He praised Zvada’s potential and said he believes the 23-year-old can have a long career in the NFL.
Harbaugh has also publicly supported the rookie, but Zvada’s ongoing struggles have made the decision to release Sanders harder to defend. The veteran’s success at MetLife has added to the scrutiny.
## A Rare Roster Decision to Question
Sanders’ experience at MetLife was not new. During his eight seasons with Miami, he played at the stadium at least once each year. That background makes the Giants’ choice to move on from him in favor of Zvada more difficult to explain.
The decision stands out as a potential misstep for a Giants regime that has otherwise strengthened several areas of the roster, including the offensive line, tight end, inside linebacker and secondary. Special teams, however, has been one of Harbaugh’s more challenging areas as he works to improve the unit.
If Zvada cannot resolve his technical issues, the Giants may need to consider another option at kicker.