The New Orleans Saints missed a chance to move into first place in the NFC South in Week 10, even as the Carolina Panthers committed 17 penalties for 152 yards. The loss wasn’t solely on quarterback Tyler Shough, but his performance added to the questions facing a team that entered the season as a dark-horse contender and now sits at 3-6, behind the 4-5 Panthers.
New Orleans made no acquisitions at the trade deadline, instead trading Davon Godchaux and releasing Kendre Miller. Those moves suggested the Saints may not view themselves as serious contenders this season. Still, the NFC South remains within reach, leaving the team a chance to play meaningful games late in the year.
The quarterback position, however, could become a bigger focus. Shough is in his second NFL season after being selected in the second round of the 2025 draft. He was the oldest quarterback in his draft class, which may factor into questions about his long-term potential. ESPN analyst Ben Solak believes the Saints may need to consider a change.
## ESPN Analyst Sees a Possible Need for a New Quarterback
Solak wrote that he believes New Orleans needs a new starting quarterback in 2027. He was particularly concerned by Shough’s showing against Carolina.
The Saints scored 17 points on 11 drives and averaged 3.6 yards per play, their lowest mark of the season outside their game against the Vikings’ defense. Solak also noted that 40% of Shough’s throws were behind the line of scrimmage and 80% traveled fewer than 10 yards downfield. Both figures were career highs for the quarterback, and the 40% rate was among the highest for any quarterback in a game that season.
Solak also highlighted plays in which Shough passed up opportunities to throw deeper downfield. The performance was disappointing against a Panthers defense that had fired its defensive coordinator, was without both starting cornerbacks, and ranked 22nd in expected points added per drive and 27th in points allowed per drive entering the game.
## Potential Quarterback Options for New Orleans
Solak raised the possibility that the Saints could turn back to Spencer Rattler or add a veteran on a minimum contract in the offseason. He pointed to Atlanta’s signing of Tua Tagovailoa as a backup to Michael Penix Jr. as one example of that approach.
Depending on how the rest of the season unfolds, quarterbacks such as Kyler Murray and Daniel Jones could be available. New Orleans could also consider selecting a quarterback early in the 2027 NFL Draft.
Shough is only two years into his NFL career, so he may not be pushed out of New Orleans after the season. But after the performance against Carolina, his position as the Saints’ long-term starter appears less secure.