The Pittsburgh Steelers entered Sunday night’s matchup with the Cincinnati Bengals expecting a tough contest. The teams had been separated by just three points when they met in Week 3, but this game proved far more one-sided. Pittsburgh lost 38–18 after struggling on both sides of the ball, raising questions about the team’s preparation, execution, and identity.
Here are three key takeaways from the defeat and what the Steelers need to address before their next game.
## 1. Pittsburgh’s Offense Lacked a Reliable Plan
Cincinnati may be the stronger team, but the Bengals’ 20-point victory reflected serious problems in Pittsburgh’s performance. The Steelers struggled to establish their preferred style of play and did not appear to have an effective alternative once the Bengals disrupted their plans.
Quarterback Aaron Rodgers started the game 0-for-8 and did not complete his first pass until nearly halftime. Pittsburgh also failed to get its running game going. The Bengals focused on stopping Jaylen Warren, who managed just 15 yards on seven carries. His longest run went for only six yards.
That made it difficult for the Steelers to create balance or sustain drives. When the running game was contained, the passing attack did not provide a consistent answer.
Head coach Mike McCarthy described the result as a disappointing performance and credited Cincinnati for executing its preferred style of football. He also said Pittsburgh had not steered the game in the direction it wanted and that the showing fell short of the team’s standards.
The defeat highlighted how vulnerable the offense can be when its primary plan is taken away. Pittsburgh has an experienced quarterback, but its receiving group has offered limited production beyond Germie Bernard. If the Steelers cannot run effectively or find dependable options in the passing game, opposing defenses have fewer threats to account for.
## 2. Mason McCormick’s Injury Could Affect the Steelers’ Identity
Pittsburgh’s offensive problems were made worse by an injury to guard Mason McCormick. He hurt his ankle during the game and was carted off the field. An air cast was placed on his right ankle after a collision with the Bengals’ defensive line.
The full extent of the injury was not known after the game. Given how the play looked, however, the Steelers could be without McCormick for a significant stretch. A short absence would be a favorable outcome for Pittsburgh, but the team must prepare for the possibility that he will miss more time.
Spencer Anderson is expected to step in at left guard if McCormick is unavailable. Anderson has not played consistently since McCarthy benched him and Dylan Cook in favor of Brock Hoffman and Max Iheanachor. His return to a starting role would put added pressure on him to provide stability up front.
The offensive line is especially important to a team that wants to build its attack around the run. With Warren limited to seven carries against Cincinnati, Pittsburgh needs its blockers to help restore that part of the offense. Anderson will have an opportunity to show that his time on the bench helped him reset and prepare for the challenge.
## 3. The Defense Failed to Contain Cincinnati
The Steelers’ defense had a difficult night as well, allowing 477 yards of offense. Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow threw for 409 yards, while Ja’Marr Chase accounted for 231 receiving yards and repeatedly found room against Pittsburgh’s coverage.
The Steelers used pressure in an effort to speed up Burrow’s decisions, but the approach did not work. Cincinnati’s passing game took advantage, and Pittsburgh struggled to limit Chase’s impact.
A more conservative strategy—rushing four defenders while using double coverage on Chase and Tee Higgins—was considered a way to make life harder for the Bengals’ offense. Pittsburgh did not consistently take that approach, and the results showed how difficult it was to disrupt Cincinnati without leaving its receivers room to make plays. Zone coverage can have weaknesses, but it was viewed as a potential way to reduce the Bengals’ opportunities.
Linebacker Patrick Queen said the defense needed to settle down. He described the game plan as sound but acknowledged that Cincinnati executed better, including on plays the Steelers expected to see.
Whatever the reason, allowing nearly 500 yards is not a sustainable path to winning. Pittsburgh needs to improve its execution, communication, and ability to limit explosive plays.
## What Comes Next for Pittsburgh
The 38–18 loss was a major setback for the Steelers. Cincinnati played well, but Pittsburgh’s struggles on offense and defense made the result especially concerning. The team must now put the game behind it while addressing the issues that were exposed.
McCarthy’s immediate challenge is helping the players move on quickly and prepare for the next test: a trip across the state to face the Philadelphia Eagles. The Steelers have plenty to correct, including their rushing attack, their response when the initial offensive plan fails, and their defensive approach against a dangerous passing game.
The loss does not settle the course of Pittsburgh’s season, but the team will need a much stronger performance against Philadelphia. If the Steelers can improve the areas that failed against Cincinnati, there is still hope for their season.