The New England Patriots’ season was in trouble before Thanksgiving, and an injury to quarterback Drake Maye added to their concerns. Maye was hurt on the opening drive of the team’s game against the Detroit Lions in Munich, Germany. Lions defensive end Aidan Hutchinson sacked him in a tackle that drew questions about whether it was an illegal hip-drop. Maye injured his ankle on the play and did not return. His status for upcoming games was uncertain. Hutchinson also injured himself while celebrating the sack.
Hip-drop tackles have become a focus of debate among NFL fans and officials. The technique generally involves a defender tackling an opponent from behind, swiveling and landing on the player’s lower legs. The league has introduced rules against the maneuver because of the injury risk, though these plays are not always penalized.
## NFL Rules Expert Weighs In on the Tackle
After Maye was ruled out, Fox analyst Greg Olsen said the play looked like a hip-drop tackle that could potentially lead to a fine. NFL rules expert Mike Pereira disagreed, saying the play did not meet the rule’s definition.
“There is [a lot of conversation], but it’s not a hip-drop,” Pereira said during the broadcast. “Three things have to happen. You have to unweight yourself, swivel all around the back, and land on the back of his legs below the knee.”
Pereira described the tackle as an awkward play that more closely resembled a horse-collar tackle, another dangerous maneuver that is prohibited. However, he said it did not meet that definition either, calling it “more of a horse collar type, pulled down from behind,” but “not a horse collar.”
Patriots fans may disagree with Pereira’s assessment, but his explanation was that the tackle did not meet the specific criteria for a hip-drop or horse-collar penalty. Regardless of the ruling, Maye’s injury was a major concern for a team that needed its quarterback to make a push for the playoffs.
## Former NFL Doctor Offers an Injury Assessment
Following the injury, former NFL doctor David J. Chao offered an assessment based on video of the play. He suggested Maye had a mild right high-ankle sprain and noted that the ankle appeared to be caught at the end of the tackle.
That assessment was not based on an in-person examination. Without examining Maye, Chao could not confirm the precise injury or its severity. The Patriots’ outlook would depend in part on how serious the ankle injury proved to be, as Maye’s absence would pose a significant challenge for the offense.