An interception by Arch Manning against LSU on November 14 sparked a debate about officiating after ESPN analyst Kirk Herbstreit said a penalty should have been called on the play. As Manning tried to get rid of the ball under pressure, an LSU defender appeared to pull him backward by the collar area. The officials let the play continue, and LSU turned the turnover into a promising scoring opportunity.
The incident unfolded in the first half. Manning attempted to escape pressure and send a pass downfield, but his off-balance throw sailed high. LSU defensive back Ty Benefield intercepted it and returned the ball 31 yards to the Texas 16-yard line.
During the ABC broadcast, Herbstreit questioned whether LSU defensive lineman Jordan Ross had committed a horse-collar foul by grabbing the back-collar area of Manning’s shoulder pads and jersey. Former SEC referee and rules analyst Matt Austin agreed that the contact appeared to meet the definition of the penalty.
“ That definitely meets the definition of a horse collar,” Herbstreit said.
The broadcast discussion focused on whether Ross’s contact warranted a flag, even though Manning was throwing the ball rather than being brought down in a conventional tackle. Had officials called the penalty, the interception would have been nullified, and Texas would have received a 15-yard penalty and an automatic first down.
The no-call quickly became a point of disagreement among fans. Some supported Herbstreit and Austin’s assessment, arguing that the replay showed a clear violation. One viewer wrote, “I mean it’s pretty clear a horse collar.” Another echoed the view with, “Def horse collar.”
Others expressed frustration with the officiating. “No shit. Refs suck,” one viewer commented, reflecting the reaction of fans who believed the missed call could have changed the course of the possession.
Not everyone thought Texas had been treated unfairly, however. Some viewers argued that the play deserved closer scrutiny for possible holding by a Texas player. One fan wrote, “Texas should have been called for holding too.” Another made a similar point, noting that the LSU defender appeared to be held during the action.
Those contrasting reactions shaped the debate around the interception. Herbstreit and Austin focused on the contact against Manning, while critics said officials should also have considered whether Texas committed a foul. The discussion therefore became about more than the quarterback’s inaccurate pass: it centered on whether the referees had missed one violation—or potentially more than one.
The play also drew attention because Herbstreit had commented on another Manning interception earlier in the season. During Texas’ 34-27 win over No. 7 Ole Miss on October 24, Manning threw an interception with the game tied 24-24 in the fourth quarter. He attempted a deep pass into coverage, where two defenders were in the area, and Ole Miss defensive back Jalyn Crawford came away with the ball.
Herbstreit described that throw as a “poor decision” during the ABC broadcast and questioned why Manning tried to force the pass into coverage. That turnover did not lead to points for Ole Miss. Manning later responded with a one-yard rushing touchdown, helping Texas regain the lead.
The criticism of the Ole Miss throw differed from Herbstreit’s response to the LSU play. In the earlier game, he focused on Manning’s decision-making. Against LSU, his objection was directed at the officials’ decision to let the play stand, with Austin backing his interpretation of the apparent contact.
Herbstreit had also expressed confidence in Texas before the season. In August, he said he would be surprised if the team did not have a big year, pointing to Manning’s improvement after Texas finished the 2025 season with six wins in its final seven games.
The LSU interception thus became the latest moment to fuel debate about Manning and Texas, but the main dispute was not simply about the quarterback’s throw. It was whether Ross’s contact met the standard for a horse-collar penalty, and whether any potential holding by Texas should have been called as well. With the interception standing and LSU taking possession near the goal line, fans were left divided over the officials’ decision.