The Dallas Cowboys are 4–5, but their record alone does not explain Dak Prescott’s contribution. The quarterback has made mistakes, including costly turnovers in losses to Tampa Bay and Green Bay. Those errors deserve criticism. But blaming Prescott for everything that has gone wrong in Dallas overlooks the value he has provided.
One advanced statistic offers a useful perspective. In a November 12 ranking of the NFL’s most valuable players at each position, Prescott placed second among quarterbacks in Pro Football Focus’s Wins Above Replacement (WAR) metric, with a score of 1.85.
That ranking does not resolve every debate about Prescott. It does, however, provide evidence that his overall contribution has been among the league’s most significant at his position—and raises a broader question: Is Dallas making enough of what its quarterback brings to the offense?
## What Prescott’s WAR Ranking Shows
WAR estimates a player’s contribution compared with a replacement-level alternative. PFF’s model draws on its play-by-play evaluations, player participation, and the value of different responsibilities.
A score of 1.85 does not mean Prescott personally delivered exactly 1.85 Dallas victories. Nor does it prove he is the league’s second-best quarterback in every situation. WAR is one measure, not a definitive ranking of every player or performance.
Its value is that it offers a way to assess a player’s accumulated contribution beyond the team’s win-loss record. A team can have a disappointing season while still receiving substantial value from its quarterback. Recognizing that distinction can help the Cowboys identify where their problems actually lie.
## The Supporting Numbers
Through nine games, Prescott has completed 64.9% of his passes for 2,381 yards, 16 touchdowns, and five interceptions. His five interceptions on 336 attempts amount to an interception rate of approximately 1.5%.
He has also put together a productive three-game stretch against Philadelphia, Arizona, and Indianapolis, throwing six touchdown passes without an interception. In the win over the Colts, he recorded 335 passing yards and two touchdowns.
That stretch was not mistake-free: Prescott lost a fumble against Indianapolis. His season passer rating of 95.4 also cannot, on its own, settle whether he belongs among the league’s elite quarterbacks.
Still, his production, recent ability to avoid interceptions, and high WAR ranking make it difficult to argue that Dallas simply lacks a quarterback capable of producing winning football. A more useful question is whether the Cowboys are consistently putting him in a position to do so.
## The Offense and Coaching Still Deserve Scrutiny
Brian Schottenheimer’s offensive system should be evaluated alongside Prescott’s play. The quarterback operates within that system, so his production reflects the offense’s design as well as his own execution. At the same time, a quarterback’s success does not make the play-calling immune from criticism.
Dallas has faced questions about how it uses motion and whether it creates favorable opportunities before the snap. Motion can help reveal defensive coverage, change a matchup, or give a receiver a better chance to avoid contact at the line. But movement should serve a purpose; it is not automatically beneficial simply because it changes the formation.
There is also a practical consideration: motion can affect protection responsibilities and help the offense identify coverage. Its usefulness depends on the formation and the play being run. The question is not whether Dallas should use motion on every play, but whether its choices are helping the offense.
Is the team consistently creating a clean first read for Prescott? Are receivers getting favorable releases? And when the initial plan is not working, does the offense adjust? Those questions are relevant to coaching even when the quarterback is playing well.
## Play-Action Is a Starting Point, Not a Cure-All
Through Week 9, Prescott had 63 play-action pass attempts, or approximately 18.8% of his total attempts. That figure gives Dallas a concrete starting point for evaluating how it uses the concept, but it does not prove that simply increasing play-action would improve the offense.
Those attempts produced 453 yards, or about 7.2 yards per attempt. That is only slightly higher than Prescott’s overall average of 7.1 yards per attempt.
The Cowboys should therefore look at when and how they call play-action rather than assume that the concept automatically creates an advantage. The goal is to influence defenders and open useful throwing windows. Schottenheimer’s calls should be judged by whether they create those opportunities consistently, while Prescott should be evaluated on how well he recognizes and completes them.
## The Bottom Line
Prescott’s second-place WAR ranking strengthens the case that he has been one of the NFL’s most valuable quarterbacks this season. It does not erase his mistakes, settle every question about his career, or excuse uneven offensive performances.
It does offer a reason to look beyond Dallas’ 4–5 record when assessing his play. The Cowboys appear to have a quarterback delivering substantial value. Their challenge is to turn that contribution into a more dependable offense.
Schottenheimer must create favorable situations, and Prescott must capitalize on them. Dallas should assess both responsibilities instead of reducing a complicated team problem to whether its quarterback deserves the label “elite.” The more immediate priority is making better use of the player it already has.