New England Patriots quarterback Drake Maye left the team’s Week 10 game against the Detroit Lions in Munich with a right ankle injury after a sack by Lions defensive end Aidan Hutchinson. Officials did not throw a flag on the play, prompting an immediate debate among fans and football commentators over whether the tackle should have been penalized as an illegal hip-drop.
The incident occurred on New England’s opening drive at Allianz Arena. After a 26-yard flea-flicker pass to Mack Hollins, penalties pushed the Patriots back. On third-and-goal, Hutchinson came from behind and brought Maye down, landing across the quarterback’s lower legs. Maye twisted his right ankle during the tackle, limped off the field and was later ruled out for the remainder of the game.
The absence of a penalty drew strong reactions online. Some fans argued that the tackle appeared to meet the NFL’s definition of a hip-drop, while others questioned whether the full set of requirements had been met.
Reporter Mark Maske noted that the tackle had prompted hip-drop comparisons, adding that some elements of the technique appeared to be present. Under NFL rules, however, a tackle is not illegal simply because a defender lands on a runner’s legs. The required elements must all occur: the defender must grab or wrap up the runner, unweight himself, swivel and then fall onto or trap the runner’s leg or legs at or below the knee.
FOX analyst Greg Olsen described the play as a hip-drop tackle that had gone uncalled and suggested it could still result in a fine. NFL rules analyst Mike Pereira viewed it differently. Pereira said the tackle looked more like a horse-collar-style pull from behind, although he did not consider it a horse-collar tackle. He also acknowledged that the play was awkward and resembled a dangerous form of tackle.
Replay footage circulated on social media, where viewers disputed the officials’ decision. Some fans said Hutchinson’s movement looked like the technique the league sought to prohibit. Others criticized the interpretation offered during the broadcast and asked for clearer explanations of how the rule was being applied. The disagreement reflected a broader frustration among fans about whether hip-drop tackles are being called consistently.
The NFL banned the hip-drop tackle in March 2024, citing the injury risk associated with the technique. In the rule’s description, a defender first grabs or wraps up a runner, then unweights himself, swivels his hips or lower body, and drops onto or traps the runner’s legs at or below the knee. The league said this type of tackle causes lower-body injuries at a rate 20 times higher than other tackles.
The potential consequences can be significant. In 2023, Baltimore Ravens tight end Mark Andrews suffered a fractured left fibula and ankle ligament damage after Cincinnati Bengals linebacker Logan Wilson rolled up his leg during a tackle. In 2024, Tampa Bay Buccaneers receiver Chris Godwin dislocated his ankle, an injury that required surgery and ended his season.
When officials identify a hip-drop tackle during a game, the defense is penalized 15 yards and the offense receives an automatic first down. A player may also be fined afterward if the play was missed in real time. Linebacker Roquan Smith, for example, was fined $16,833 for a tackle on Godwin.
The relevant language appears in Rule 12, Section 2, Article 18 of the NFL Rulebook. It defines a foul as bringing a runner down by grabbing him with one or both hands, or wrapping him with both arms, and then unweighting, swiveling and dropping the hips or lower body so the defender lands on or traps the runner’s leg or legs at or below the knee.
Hutchinson also left the game with an injury shortly after the sack. Following a celebration, he landed awkwardly on his right knee, entered the blue medical tent and limped toward Detroit’s locker room. The Lions ruled him out with a knee injury but had not confirmed its severity.
The sequence prompted some fans to describe Hutchinson’s injury as “instant karma,” while others focused on the apparent twist to Maye’s ankle and the lack of a penalty. Neither reaction resolved the central question: whether the play met every element required for an illegal hip-drop tackle.
Before leaving, Maye completed three of four passes for 48 yards and ran for 11 yards. His work helped kicker Andres Borregales make a 33-yard field goal. Backup quarterback Tommy DeVito took over, and New England punted on its next four possessions before Detroit cornerback Roger McCreary intercepted him.
Detroit continued to control the game despite losing Hutchinson on the opening drive. The Lions had 467 total yards while building a 35-10 lead in the fourth quarter, and they finished with 494 yards.
The sack, Maye’s injury and the dispute over the uncalled penalty became the game’s most closely scrutinized moments, adding an off-field rules debate to a difficult day for New England.