Facing a sibling in an NFL game is an unusual challenge, and Caleb and Josh Downs experienced it firsthand when the Dallas Cowboys met the Indianapolis Colts in Week 9. The brothers discussed the matchup days later on their podcast, *Downs 2 Business*, where Caleb described how often his teammates and coaches brought Josh up during the week.
“There was a lot of emphasis on you, honestly. Just like because you were the motion guy,” Caleb said. He explained that many of the Colts’ offensive routes depended on Josh’s timing, including plays in which the receiver cleared space or ran crossing routes.
Caleb said he had not practiced much during the week, so he was not paying close attention to the field unless people were discussing his brother. Josh’s name kept coming up, and Caleb wondered whether that was simply because the two were related.
“Everybody kept looking at me when they bring your name up,” he recalled. “And then they were just like, ‘Are you going to be okay? Are you going to be okay with guarding your brother?’”
## A family connection—and a competitive matchup
Caleb and Josh are about three and a half years apart. Although they play for different teams, the brothers have maintained a close relationship. Josh attended Caleb’s draft ceremony and became emotional as his younger brother’s name was announced. During the broadcast, Josh said Caleb had “always been the best player in the field.”
That pride did not stop Josh from looking forward to competing against him. The brothers had even discussed the possibility before the game. Josh previously said Caleb had told him that if he joined the Cowboys, he would play nickel. That defensive role could place Caleb directly across from Josh, a wide receiver.
Josh approached the matchup with the kind of teasing confidence familiar between siblings. “It’s all fun and games, but, you know, I gotta still let him know he’s the little brother,” he said.
The game gave Caleb an early opportunity to back up that confidence on the field. He had the stronger individual result in their direct matchups, holding Josh without a catch on two targets when he was covering him. Caleb also contributed to a much-needed Cowboys victory.
Afterward, he said the team result mattered most, while acknowledging how unusual it felt to line up against his brother.
“We needed the win as a team, that’s the biggest thing,” Caleb said. “It was a surreal feeling going out there and lining up in front of him and it’s me and him the whole game. I was thankful for the situation.”
He also recognized that Josh had opportunities during the game. “He definitely got me in some of the plays that they missed him on,” Caleb said. He was grateful that both brothers were healthy and that their family could attend.
## Caleb supports Josh after a difficult outing
Caleb’s support for his brother extended beyond the matchup itself. He defended Josh after a frustrating performance, emphasizing that one game—or a lack of opportunities to catch the ball—should not change how a player sees himself.
“At the end of the day, he’s a ball player and he can’t think of himself any differently based off of one play or not getting the ball thrown to him,” Caleb said. “He plays his a— off.”
Josh’s next opportunity came with a new team. The Colts traded him to the Kansas City Chiefs, who needed more production at wide receiver after their depth at the position had diminished. Before the trade, Josh had been leading Indianapolis in receiving yards, making him a potential solution for Kansas City as the offense relied heavily on tight end Travis Kelce.
Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes praised Josh’s ability to learn and prepare. “You can tell just the intellect and how he’s able to pick stuff up. He’s a professional,” Mahomes said. “He knows what he’s doing, and he wants to come in and just compete and have success.”
The move also changed the brothers’ immediate NFL outlook. The Cowboys and Chiefs are not scheduled to meet during the 2026 regular season, so Caleb will not face Josh for a second time that year. Their Week 9 meeting remains a memorable moment in both players’ careers: a family milestone, a competitive test and a reminder that the bond between the Downs brothers continued beyond the game.