Ohio State’s 28–19 victory over Northwestern gave Ryan Day’s team a needed result after consecutive losses and kept the Buckeyes’ playoff hopes alive. The win also brought renewed attention to the team’s defense—and to a fourth-quarter hit on Northwestern quarterback Nicco Marchiol that rules analyst Terry McAulay believes should have prompted a targeting review.
McAulay questioned the officials’ decision not to review the play. In his assessment, Ohio State defensive end Kenyatta Jackson Jr. appeared to lead with his forearm and make forceful contact with Marchiol’s head or neck area as the quarterback was releasing a pass.
“I’m surprised this wasn’t reviewed for targeting. He takes aim for the purpose of attacking the head. He leads with the forearm. He makes forcible contact with the forearm to the head/neck area of a defenseless player,” McAulay wrote.
The play occurred as Marchiol prepared to throw. Jackson Jr. made contact around the moment the ball was released, and Marchiol went to the ground after the collision. The officials did not throw a flag, and the play did not lead to a targeting review.
McAulay’s criticism centers on how the NCAA rulebook defines targeting and which players are considered defenseless. Under the rule, a player may not target a defenseless opponent in the head or neck area with the helmet, forearm, hand, fist, elbow or shoulder. The rule also identifies leading with the forearm to make forcible contact with an opponent’s head or neck as an indicator of targeting.
A quarterback who has just released a pass is considered defenseless under the rule. That detail is central to McAulay’s argument that the play warranted closer examination. However, the officials did not review the hit, and the game continued without a targeting penalty being assessed.
The debate comes as Ohio State seeks to regain momentum late in the season. The Buckeyes entered the Northwestern game needing a response after back-to-back defeats, and the 28–19 result provided one. But the disputed play has drawn attention to the fine line officials must assess when determining whether contact meets the criteria for targeting.
The game also marked a notable improvement for Ohio State’s pass rush. The Buckeyes had recorded only two sacks over their previous four games, but they brought down Marchiol five times against Northwestern. Jackson Jr. contributed two of those sacks, helping provide the defense with a stronger presence in the backfield.
Jackson Jr. was also penalized during the game. In the fourth quarter, he received a 15-yard penalty. It was another entry in his disciplinary record after he had been called for a five-yard defensive delay-of-game penalty on September 13, 2025, against the Bobcats. Beyond those penalties, his record had otherwise been clean.
Ohio State’s defensive performance gave the team reasons for optimism, particularly after its recent struggles creating pressure. Still, the discussion surrounding Jackson Jr.’s hit may continue because McAulay believes the play met the criteria for a targeting review. The distinction matters: the analyst criticized the lack of a review, but no targeting penalty was called during the game.
For Day and the Buckeyes, the Northwestern victory offered a chance to steady the season and keep their postseason hopes in view. The team’s defense generated more pressure, and Jackson Jr. played a significant role in that effort. At the same time, the disputed contact serves as a reminder that decisions involving player safety can become a focus even after a win. Ohio State will need to keep its discipline and execution consistent as it moves forward.