The two also crossed paths in New York, playing for the Jets at different times. Scott was with the Jets from 2009 to 2012, while Colon joined the Jets from 2013 to 2015. They now host a podcast through Playmaker, known for a wide range of guest appearances and engaging football-focused discussions. The show has featured notable guests and continues to attract football enthusiasts for its fall programming.
What sets Scott and Colon apart in the crowded field of former-athlete podcasts is their authenticity. Their chemistry is evident as they blend quick wit with blunt humor, often poking fun at themselves and each other while covering football, daily life, and bold humor. In a one-on-one interview, Scott described their dynamic as a natural fit: both self-deprecating and approachable, with a strong desire to own and control their narrative as they expand their platform.
Why podcasting appeals to Scott over traditional media is clear. He notes that podcasts offer freedom to be genuine without the constraints of traditional broadcast formats and sponsor considerations. After 13 years in the business and years watching the media landscape evolve, he appreciates the ability to present the full spectrum of his personality—serious, playful, intelligent, and occasionally irreverent—on their own terms.
Colon echoes the value of authenticity, highlighting how podcasts let athletes share unfiltered perspectives outside the limitations of traditional beats, PR, or brand alignments. He emphasizes that the podcast space enables them to present their true identities, in contrast to relying on beat writers or public relations narratives. This raw, personal approach helps the duo stand out in an era where technology can blur lines between real and synthetic media, keeping their discourse honest and accountable.
Their ongoing friendship traces back to a shared professional history, including work together covering the Jets regionally and collaborating in media ventures. Both men are committed to presenting a relatable, family-centered perspective as Black men carving out space in the media landscape, delivering unapologetic honesty while staying true to themselves.
If you’re following their work, you’ll find two experienced athletes who have turned rivals into allies, using their platform to engage audiences with authentic conversations, self-awareness, and a distinctive voice in sports media.
