Among the Buccaneers’ legitimate trade assets, Diaby is viewed as having the most trade value. However, his current contract year has dampened his appeal. Teams may be wary of paying in the range of $20 million to $25 million for a player who primarily plays run defense and does not consistently reach the quarterback for big-numbered sacks.
Diaby, a former third-round pick, is in the final year of his rookie deal. He has started every season and has not missed a game in 56 appearances, and he began his career strong with 7.5 sacks as a rookie. Since then, his production has fluctuated: 4.5 sacks in 2024, improved run defense in 2025 with seven sacks, but this year he has zero sacks and only seven pressures, placing him in a challenging spot for both himself and the Buccaneers.
The Buccaneers face a decision about Diaby. Extending him could be challenging given his pending market value, especially if he finishes the year strong and becomes a sought-after free agent. If he struggles, he remains a productive 27-year-old pass rusher with 18.5 sacks across three seasons and solid run defense, which could still attract interest from other teams. However, the Buccaneers may weigh whether to invest long-term in a player whose production has plateaued.
If Tampa Bay receives a fourth-round pick offer, accepting could be the straightforward move to recoup value, especially if it helps future flexibility, even if it means parting with a player who might contribute to a late-season push. The decision will hinge on how Diaby finishes the year and how the Buccaneers value their present playoff prospects versus future assets.
