Several analysts argued that Lloyd’s early outlook suggested trouble ahead. One perspective highlighted the Packers’ offensive usage, noting that Lloyd played under 50% of offensive snaps while Chris Brooks handled a larger share on passing downs. Brooks logged about 56% of Green Bay’s offensive snaps in that game, marking a career milestone of surpassing the 50% mark in snaps for the first time in his 42nd NFL contest.
The concern extended beyond that game. Critics pointed out that the Packers have not historically trusted Brooks with heavy workloads, despite his three years with the team. In addition, Kaleb Johnson was acquired through a trade and could gradually be integrated into the mix, potentially stealing touches as he learns the playbook.
The argument against Lloyd centers on the team’s preference for Brooks in passing situations, which inherently caps Lloyd’s ceiling. If the Packers choose to lean on a specialist for third-down duties, Lloyd’s upside may remain limited, even if his floor remains modest.
From a tactical standpoint, there is a glimmer of potential. In the same game, Brooks logged more passing-down snaps (30) compared to Lloyd (16), while Lloyd was on the field for 13 rushing plays to Brooks’ eight. If the Packers build a lead, Lloyd could see more work, potentially translating into productive fantasy outings. Yet the overarching takeaway is that Lloyd’s path to a true every-down role appears constrained if Brooks continues to occupy the passing-down role.
Kaleb Johnson enters the conversation as a possible breakout candidate for the Packers. Johnson, a younger player and the highest-drafted back among the group, was acquired during roster moves and did not see offensive snaps in Week 1. His potential rise could cut into Lloyd’s workload if he proves capable of contributing on offense. As Johnson becomes more acclimated to the system, there is a plausible scenario in which he competes for and absorbs more carries, further complicating Lloyd’s fantasy outlook.
In summary, Lloyd’s early-season performance and usage pattern raise questions about his immediate fantasy viability. The combination of Brooks’ continued involvement on passing downs and Johnson’s potential emergence suggests that Lloyd may struggle to secure a consistent, volume-heavy role. For fantasy players seeking certainty, it may be prudent to reassess Lloyd’s value, considering the likelihood that his ceiling is limited unless the Packers alter their usage strategy or Johnson proves to be a significant factor in the offense.
