Monken cited the reasons behind keeping Watson in the lineup for Week 2, noting that the quarterback had only recently returned to game action after a lengthy absence. He pointed to positives seen on the game film against the Jacksonville Jaguars, while acknowledging areas that require improvement. Watson had 16 completions on 22 attempts for 205 yards, with one touchdown and one interception, marking a modest but not flawless showing after 693 days away from playing in the NFL.
The Browns’ practice week featured a 50-50 split in quarterback reps during training camp between Watson and rookie Shedeur Sanders, which Monken said contributed to Watson still finding his rhythm. He emphasized that there are concepts—such as red-zone and third-down plays—that sometimes generate different looks from week to week, and that Watson looked more decisive when he had time and wasn’t playing tentatively.
Despite the cautious endorsement, Monken made it clear that Watson’s hold on the starting job isn’t guaranteed to last beyond the next game if the results don’t improve. The team faces a crucial test in Week 3 on the road against the Carolina Panthers, a matchup many will view as a pressure point for Watson and Cleveland’s offense.
Several factors outside the on-field performance complicate the situation. The Browns have a storied history with their former No. 1 overall pick, Baker Mayfield, who helped lead the Buccaneers in 2023 after being traded away by Cleveland in 2022. Mayfield’s continued success with Tampa Bay raises the stakes for Watson, especially if Cleveland were to suffer another setback and fans grow louder in their dissatisfaction. Any strong performance by Mayfield against his former team would amplify the conversation about Cleveland’s 2022 decision and put additional scrutiny on Watson’s tenure.
Another dimension to watch is the venue. The Browns opened the season with two straight road games and will face their home crowd for Week 3 against the Panthers. The home environment could intensify any lingering friction with fans, particularly if Watson struggles again or if the team’s record remains underwhelming early in the season. Previously, preseason sentiment suggested a divided fan base, with some booing Watson at times, underscoring the emotional stakes of his return.
Monken concluded by stressing that the team must support Watson more effectively. He cited the need for better play-calling and for Watson to be sharper in execution, especially when opportunities arise. If the offense can build on the positives seen in the early performance and address the operational hiccups, Watson could stabilize the quarterback position for a stretch. However, if Week 3 fails to yield meaningful improvement, the Browns may face a pivotal decision about the quarterback role moving forward.
For now, the plan remains to keep Watson as the starter, with an emphasis on growth and better execution in the weeks ahead. Fans and observers will be watching closely as Cleveland aims to turn the page and capitalize on a favorable matchup in Week 3.
