Dallas faces a clear need at linebacker, a concern highlighted by recent developments. Starting middle linebacker DeMarvion Overshown sustained a hamstring injury during the loss to the Giants and is expected to miss at least one week. Given Overshown’s injury history since being selected in the 2023 draft, there’s legitimate worry that the absence could extend beyond a week. Overshown has served as the “green dot” communicator on the field, but he did not standout in that role during the game. In his absence, third-round rookie Jaishawn Barham stepped in, yet he has limited experience at middle linebacker, which underscores the need for a veteran presence in the middle.
A veteran like Wagner would bring immediate stability to the defense. Even with the addition of Dee Winters, who was acquired for a fifth-round pick, the linebacker group comprised of Winters, Overshown, Barham, and Shemar James still appeared thin. Wagner could provide a stabilizing force in the middle, helping to prevent breakdowns and communicate effectively with younger players.
There is precedent for Cowboys interest in a veteran linebacker. Brian Schottenheimer, who previously coached with Wagner in Seattle, has spoken highly of the player, noting that Wagner remains at a high level of play. Schottenheimer has described Wagner as one of his strongest supporters, citing the value of a veteran presence who can steady the defense when the game gets chaotic.
Wagner is not a spring chicken, but his track record speaks for itself: six All-Pro selections, 10 Pro Bowls, a Super Bowl ring, and appearances in the lineup since 2018 without missing a game until recent seasons. Last year, he finished fifth in the NFL with 162 tackles, underscoring his continued impact despite age. The Cowboys have shown a willingness to pursue veteran leadership when needed, and Wagner’s familiarity with a defensive system and his leadership qualities could be appealing to the coaching staff.
Key considerations for any potential move include cost, cap implications, and fit within Dallas’s defensive schemes. While Crosby would be a compelling addition in terms of talent, the price tag and draft capital hit could be prohibitive. Wagner, as a free agent, would likely present a more practical option if Dallas is prioritizing immediate help without sacrificing future assets. His leadership and durability—paired with his on-field production—could be the missing piece that helps this defense shore up the middle and maintain better overall communication.
In evaluating options, the Cowboys must weigh not only the on-field benefits but also the locker-room impact. A veteran like Wagner could help stabilize the defense during a challenging stretch of the schedule, while younger players continue to develop. If Dallas is serious about improving their status on defense, particularly at linebacker, pursuing Wagner appears to be a logical and feasible path that aligns with their current needs and cap reality.
For fans, the discussion centers on whether the team prioritizes high-end, capital-intensive acquisitions or pragmatic moves that address immediate needs with less risk. Wagner’s experience and proven production make him an attractive option, especially if he is open to contributing in a leadership role while mentoring the younger linebackers on the roster. As Week 2 unfolds and the schedule intensifies, the Cowboys’ approach to linebacker upgrades will be closely watched by supporters hoping for a more cohesive and resilient defensive unit.
