Background on expectations and performance
Neal was viewed as a foundational piece for the Giants’ offensive line when he was taken near the top of the first round. However, his time in New York was hampered by injuries and inconsistent play, preventing him from reaching the level of reliability the organization hoped for at his position.
Playing time and role
During his tenure with the Giants, Neal appeared in 29 regular-season games and started 27 of them. He opened his rookie season by starting all 13 games he played, but he never solidified himself as a dependable long-term option at right tackle. In an effort to salvage the investment, the team experimented with moving him inside to guard. The coaching staff, including a new head coach, gave Neal another chance by re-signing him to a one-year deal after declining his fifth-year option. Unfortunately, this last opportunity did not yield the desired results.
Draft class context
The release adds another chapter of disappointment from New York’s 2022 draft class. That year’s selections included Kayvon Thibodeaux, who has shown flashes but has had his own share of ups and downs, and Neal, whose career has faced persistent obstacles. In the offseason, the Giants reshaped their offensive line, drafting Francis Mauigoa at No. 10 overall and bringing in veteran depth. Neal was unable to break into the team’s plans despite the position switch.
Tree of potential for Neal
At 6-foot-7 and 340 pounds, Neal possesses the physical traits that once made him a highly regarded prospect out of Alabama. A change of scenery and a different coaching approach could still present another path for him, as some teams look for a project to develop into a contributor in the right system. Regardless, his time with the Giants has come to an end.
Looking ahead
Neal is just 25 years old, and he retains the potential to land with another NFL organization that believes a different environment could unlock his ability. For the Giants, this move marks the formal conclusion of a high-profile chapter that did not unfold as hoped, as they continue to build and refine their offensive line for the future.
