Knoth sits as the Brewers’ ninth-ranked prospect per MLB Pipeline and their third-ranked pitcher in the organization. The team selected Knoth 33rd overall out of Patchogue-Medford High School in New York, signing him to a below-slot deal worth $2 million. He began his professional career in 2024 in the Class A level, appearing in 21 games (21 starts) with a 4-6 record and a 4.48 ERA. After missing all of the 2025 season while rehabbing from Tommy John surgery, Knoth returned to action this year starting in Rookie Ball and quickly earned higher ownership of responsibilities.
Since his return, Knoth has progressed through the system, receiving a second promotion in 2026 to the Double-A level. At 6 feet 1 inch tall, the 21-year-old right-hander has compiled a 5-3 record with a 4.34 ERA across 19 appearances, including 17 starts, in the current minor league season. These performances illustrate his continued development and potential as a future starting pitcher in Milwaukee’s rotation.
Despite the promising trajectory, there are note-worthy concerns about Knoth’s control. In scouting reports, his command has been identified as an area to improve, especially in the wake of his Tommy John rehabilitation. Evaluators have pointed to a walk rate that has raised questions about control consistency as he advances to higher levels of competition. Nevertheless, scouts view his raw stuff as compelling, with the potential to develop into a reliable starter if he can refine his control and maintain pace with a rigorous innings plan.
Scouting notes highlight Knoth’s present velocity and repertoire. He has demonstrated a fastball in the 91-95 mph range, with a four-seamer that generates riding action and can overpower hitters when located effectively. His secondary offerings—an upper-70s curveball and an mid-80s slider—have attracted attention for their potential to develop into above-average pitches. The curveball has shown promising depth, while the slider has displayed effective movement and the ability to induce swing-and-miss and weak contact from both left- and right-handed hitters. If his control improves and his breaking balls sharpen with advanced coaching, Knoth’s ceiling could align with a mid-rotation or more durable starter profile in the majors.
With the latest promotion, Knoth will have an immediate opportunity to demonstrate his growth at the Double-A level and to test his command against a higher caliber of hitter. The Brewers will be watching his development closely as the season progresses, hoping he can sustain his upside while managing workloads and refining his pitch sequencing.
Meanwhile, Milwaukee’s current season has been marked by strong performance across the organization. The major league club sits among the league’s elite, riding a steady win pace and a deep pitching staff. In recent action, the Brewers secured a decisive victory in a recent game, further reinforcing their standing as one of the league’s top teams. The club’s pitching staff—led by notable arms across the rotation—continues to receive praise for its depth and consistency, contributing to a robust overall record as they move through the schedule.
Looking ahead, Milwaukee will continue its stretch of schedule with upcoming series and potential roster moves as they approach the latter stages of the season. The organization’s focus remains on developing young pitching talent like Knoth while maintaining competitive performance at the major league level. Knoth’s progression to Double-A is a tangible sign of the Brewers’ commitment to cultivating homegrown arms who can contribute at the highest level in the future.
This season’s minor league track record for Knoth reflects a pitcher whose talent remains apparent despite a significant rehab period. If he can harness his command and continue to refine his secondary pitches, he could emerge as a compelling starting option in Milwaukee’s plans in the years ahead. For fans and observers, Knoth’s journey through the farm system offers a clear illustration of how Milwaukee develops pitching prospects and who might join the major league rotation in the near future.
