The primary reason cited for the dip was an injury he sustained last year, which sidelined him for five games. Beyond the injury, some evaluators noted uneven moments in his play after returning from the setback. One analyst described Wirfs as elite and among the best size-and-agility athletes in the game, but added that his play showed some inconsistencies during the season.
Despite the decline in some opinions, Wirfs remained highly regarded on many ballots, with multiple voters placing him in the top four. A strong upcoming season could quickly restore him to the top tier, as Wirfs has long been recognized for his athleticism and versatility.
The polling results showed a wide range of opinions on tackles across the league. Among the 22 tackles who received votes for the top-ten list, Wirfs was one of only three to remain in the top ten on every ballot, highlighting how varied perceptions can be on the position. It was noted that some voters did not include other perennial stars in their top ten, underscoring the subjective nature of these rankings. Nonetheless, Wirfs’ consistency in not dropping out of the top tier stood out, even if one ranking placed him eighth.
Looking ahead, Wirfs has the opportunity to reclaim the No. 1 spot with a strong, healthy season. He earned a Pro Bowl invitation last year despite playing only 12 games, underscoring his high level of play when healthy. His career trajectory has been notable: he spent his first three seasons at right tackle, earning All-Pro honors twice, before transitioning to the left side. In his first year at left tackle, he made the Pro Bowl, and in his second year at that position, he earned All-Pro honors. With three years of experience on both sides and now entering his seventh NFL season, Wirfs has the experience and skill to once again be among the league’s elite at left tackle.
If Wirfs can return to peak form, he could again be considered the best at his position. Some other top players in the discussion include peers who have shown longevity and durability, signaling a potentially changing landscape at the tackle position as players age and others adapt to new roles. Wirfs’ upcoming season will be pivotal in determining whether he resumes the mantle as the premier offensive tackle in the NFL.
For fans and analysts following the Buccaneers, the expectation remains that Wirfs can bounce back to his highest level with a full, healthy slate of games. His track record suggests that he has the tools to reclaim his status among the league’s elite tackles, and a standout 2026 season could reaffirm his standing atop the position.
