Packer fans call for veteran kicker to challenge rookie Trey Smack with insight and context.

The Green Bay Packers are facing a kicker competition scenario centered on rookie Trey Smack, after drafting him in the sixth round of the 2026 NFL Draft and releasing veteran Brandon McManus. Analysts, including Brent Sobleski, have argued that Green Bay should add a veteran kicker to push or potentially replace Smack during training camp due to Smack’s inconsistent spring performances. Smack’s early offseason shows included a 5-for-9 showing in open workouts, with two misses from inside 40 yards, followed by a 7-for-8 in minicamp before missing a 35-yard try in a two-minute drill. This pattern suggests that, while not definitive, elevated competition could help ensure reliability come fall.

The discussion also notes McManus’s recent decline with the Packers—24-for-30 last season and costly misses in the NFC wild-card matchup—highlighting why the team might consider a veteran upgrade even if McManus is not an option. If the Packers bring in a veteran kicker, it could lead to Smack’s job status being reevaluated, potentially sacrificing the sixth-round pick if the veteran outperforms the rookie. Overall, the key question remains: should Green Bay add a veteran kicker to compete with Trey Smack to secure a more stable kicking game for the 2026 season?

Key Takeaways:
– Trey Smack, Green Bay’s 2026 sixth-round pick, is facing veteran kicker competition due to spring inconsistencies.
– Smack’s performance ranged from solid to shaky in offseason workouts and minicamp.
– A veteran kicker could push Smack in training camp and potentially replace him, addressing reliability concerns after releasing Brandon McManus.
– The decision balances risk: a veteran addition could optimize kicking accuracy but might threaten Smack’s spot and the perceived value of drafting a kicker.