This article analyzes veteran quarterback Mason Rudolph’s standing as Pittsburgh’s backup for the 2026 season, focusing on Sports Illustrated’s ranking of the NFL’s 32 backup signal-callers. Rudolph sits near the bottom at No. 27, despite his eight-season tenure with the Steelers, including a return from a 2024 stint in Tennessee. The piece notes Pittsburgh’s depth at quarterback, with Will Howard and rookie Drew Allar also in the mix, and discusses whether Rudolph will retain the two’s role behind Aaron Rodgers, should the Jets’ win-now approach influence Pittsburgh’s plans.
Key arguments center on whether Rudolph deserves a roster spot or should be overtaken by younger quarterbacks in preseason competition. Proponents argue Rudolph’s experience and prior playoff run in 2023 justify keeping him as a capable, if inconsistent, veteran backup, while critics point to recent underwhelming performance and a potential upside from Howard or Allar. The article highlights differing views from Steelers Depot and Sports Illustrated, with internal praise for Rudolph’s reliability contrasted by rankings that place him behind players like Kenny Pickett and Mitch Trubisky, who previously held or vied for his role.
Key takeaways:
– Rudolph’s backup status for 2026 is debated, with differing assessments on his fit behind Rodgers and whether younger QBs should seize the opportunity.
– Despite a mixed 2024–2025 track record, Rudolph’s 2023 postseason performance is cited as a positive contrast to recent struggles.
– The Steelers’ QB depth includes Will Howard and Drew Allar, influencing potential roster decisions and the competitive dynamic in preseason.
