Ben Roethlisberger reacts to Steelers drafting Drew Allar in Round 3.

The Pittsburgh Steelers ignited chatter during the 2026 NFL Draft, notably after being sniped by the Philadelphia Eagles in an attempt to draft Makai Lemon, and then surprising many by using their first-round pick on Penn State quarterback Drew Allar. This move sparked debate, including comments from Ben Roethlisberger, who questioned the rationale behind selecting Allar in the first round of the draft and later in Round 3.

Drew Allar’s background is highlighted with key facts: he played in the CFP Semifinal for Penn State in 2024-25, turned 22 in March 2026, and was a five-star prospect named Mr. Ohio in 2021. Roethlisberger’s response to the selection—shared on his YouTube channel—reflects mixed feelings, noting that while Allar has physical tools, he didn’t see a standout performance in Penn State games and compared him to other quarterbacks. The discussion also contrasts Allar with Will Howard, describing Allar as a prototypical “tools” quarterback with a big arm and mobility, while Howard is praised for leadership, processing, and anticipation. Projections for their ceilings differ, with Allar’s upside likened to Josh Allen and his floor to Christian Hackenberg, and Howard’s ceiling pegged at players like Kirk Cousins or Matt Ryan, with a lower floor resembling Chase Daniel.

Key takeaways:
– The Steelers’ draft strategy generated significant controversy and sparked scrutiny from former players.
– Drew Allar’s selection is analyzed in terms of potential, with comparisons to Will Howard and varied ceiling/floor projections.
– The discussion explores how Allar’s physical traits and readiness translate to NFL success, and how his career trajectory may unfold in Pittsburgh.