The bullpen’s early-season issues have persisted from 2025. Closer David Bednar owns nine saves and leads the AL in that category, but his 4.15 ERA through nine appearances isn’t ideal. Veteran closer options like Camilo Doval have also struggled, and New York has had to lean on newer arms such as Brent Headrick, Tim Hill, and Fernando Cruz—who have shown flashes but aren’t yet trusted in high-leverage spots.
MLB insider Jon Heyman has been vocal about the Yankees’ need for a more reliable late-inning group. On MLB Insider Notebook, Heyman said the current bullpen resembles an average unit and suggested Cashman should already be exploring the reliever market, arguing that a championship-caliber bullpen is still not clearly in place for the Yankees.
Among the potential targets discussed early in the season is Kansas City Royals closer Carlos Estevez. Estevez’s injury absence this year has limited his activity, raising questions about his health status. If the Royals decide to sell at the trade deadline, Estevez could offer New York another trusted option to close or bridge games late, though any deal remains contingent on both teams’ evaluations and timing.
Even with possible acquisitions, the Yankees’ immediate strength—an improving lineup and solid starting rotation—means the focal point will remain the bullpen. Boone has done well to cobble together late-inning performances, but the team’s long-term success may hinge on adding a reliable reliever who can finish games behind Bednar.
In summary, New York’s strong overall standing and recent momentum underscore why Cashman could be motivated to act on bullpen reinforcements. As Heyman noted, a deeper, more trustworthy late-inning corps could elevate the Yankees from a solid contender to a true World Series threat, making relief help a priority in the near term.
