Devers is under a 10-year, $313.5 million contract and is under team control through 2033. He could slide into first base or serve as a designated hitter for the Mets, addressing a potential void created by Pete Alonso. At the moment, Devers is hitting .225 with 2 home runs and 8 RBIs to start the year with San Francisco.
The two prospects heading to the Giants are Jonathan Santucci and Elian Pena. Santucci is a left-handed pitcher ranked ninth in the Mets system, currently in AA, with an 0-2 record and a 5.25 ERA in three starts this season. Pena is an 18-year-old shortstop ranked eighth, in Class A, who signed with the organization in January 2025 and is hitting .333 with 1 home run and 9 RBIs.
Analyst Shaan Donohue framed the trade as a read-the-room move for the Giants, who have stumbled early and faced clubhouse tension. He noted Bryce Eldridge waiting in Triple-A as a potential first-base replacement, Pena as a rising star, and Santucci as a pitching prospect who could impact the majors by September. The deal also hinges on the financial dynamic, with San Francisco looking to move Devers’ substantial contract.
For the Mets, Devers could help offset Alonso’s absence and provide a powerful right-handed bat, though his long-term price tag is significant. Donohue described the move as a way to stem the early-season slide rather than a perfectly constructed roster fit.
The Mets remain optimistic about turning their season around, with Francisco Lindor stressing the need to rebound after a difficult stretch. New York sits at 7-15 and last in the NL East, and this trade idea highlights the level of urgency around improving the roster.
This analysis presents a hypothetical scenario for how two prospects and a star-level upgrade might reshape both franchises amid early-season pressure.
