Last season in Minnesota, McCarthy posted a 61.8 overall PFF grade and a 60.1 passing grade. Across 291 dropbacks, he threw for 1,632 yards with 11 touchdowns and 12 interceptions, adding 19 big-time throws and 15 turnover-worthy plays. He also averaged 9.5 yards per attempt downfield, with an average time to throw of 3.01 seconds, plus 156 rushing yards and four rushing touchdowns.
Even if McCarthy remains the backup, some observers believe the Vikings are unlikely to consider a trade. The rationale centers on Murray’s injury history, with analysts arguing that Minnesota would not part with McCarthy unless an obvious opportunity arises.
Historically, the Vikings have shuffled through quarterbacks, a pattern coach Kevin O’Connell has navigated by using multiple signal-callers in a single season. That context suggests McCarthy could remain in a supporting role unless ownership sees a clear, long-term need for a change at quarterback.
Adam Thielen has publicly endorsed McCarthy’s mindset, noting his winner’s edge and competitive drive. Thielen highlighted the rookie’s work ethic and his early offseason chemistry with teammates, emphasizing that McCarthy is already displaying the qualities required to compete at the NFL level.
Thielen also stressed McCarthy’s self-awareness about his development gaps. He pointed out that being drafted high and dealing with an injury early in his career can slow growth, and that McCarthy will need to address specific weaknesses to position himself as a Week 1 starter and potential long-term starter for the Vikings.
