ESPN analyst Ben Solak has argued for selecting Simpson at 21 to prepare for life after Aaron Rodgers, though he concedes that outcome looks increasingly unlikely if Rodgers returns. Solak also notes the Steelers have several pressing needs beyond quarterback, shaping the broader draft strategy.
Solak stresses that the Steelers must get younger, citing an aging roster across the defense and the quarterback position. By snap-weighted age, Pittsburgh’s roster trails only a few teams in age, with wins from veteran leaders contributing to a longer-than-desired average on both sides of the ball.
On the defensive line, Solak suggests the Steelers should not pass on strong prospects if the board falls their way. Pittsburgh’s recent role players—Jack Sawyer at defensive end, and interior players Derrick Harmon and Yahya Black—have provided varying contributions, but more youth and depth at defensive line remain a clear target.
The secondary also skews older, with Nnaji Ramsey at 31, DeShon Elliott at 29, and free-agent addition Jamel Dean approaching 30 this season, underscoring the call to infuse youth and depth in the back end.
If the draft plan diverts from Simpson at 21, Solak points to development opportunities, such as LSU’s Garrett Nussmeier, a quarterback whose background could align with Pittsburgh’s evolving roster, particularly under a head coach prioritizing familiarity and development. The overarching message is to balance immediate needs with long-term roster health by boosting the secondary and defensive line while adding a developmental quarterback.
