McShay believes Simpson is a legitimate first-round talent, noting that some teams are quietly evaluating him as a high first-round possibility—potentially top 15. However, he would prefer to see Simpson land with the Los Angeles Rams, who hold two first-round picks, as a more conducive target for immediate development and success.
Despite reservations about Cleveland, McShay acknowledges there is intrigue around the Browns, especially with the chance to work under a quarterback-friendly system led by coach Todd Monken. Simpson himself has expressed excitement about the possibility, highlighting Monken’s approach as a strong fit if the opportunity arises in Cleveland.
On the Browns’ side, the quarterback competition remains open. The roster features Shedeur Sanders, Dillon Gabriel, and Deshaun Watson, with head coach Kevin Stefanski and offensive staff indicating no clear starter has emerged. The uncertainty at QB adds to the broader discussion about how aggressively Cleveland might pursue a top quarterback prospect with the No. 6 pick.
Overall, the conversation underscores a broader trend: while Simpson is viewed as a credible first-round talent, his best-fit destination remains a matter of debate, influencing how teams weigh the risks and rewards of drafting him in the early portion of the first round.
This development comes as Cleveland continues to rebuild its offensive line and weaponry, aiming to create a more quarterback-friendly environment—whether pursuing Simpson or another top signal-caller in the 2026 class.
