According to a well-connected NFL insider, the central question for Herbig’s future hinges on whether he accepts immediate security or cashes in on a rise-the-market year by waiting for the open market in 2027. The Steelers’ willingness to price the contract appropriately will largely determine if a deal gets done this offseason.
Highsmith, already under contract through 2027, represents a complementary cornerstone to star edge-rusher T.J. Watt. With Watt turning 32 next season and Highsmith approaching 29, Pittsburgh appears intent on stabilizing the position group by potentially extending Herbig as a long-term successor alongside Highsmith.
The Steelers have cultivated a historically strong edge-rush culture, a trend that has persisted from legends of the past to current stalwarts. T.J. Watt’s prolific production and Highsmith’s consistent contributions have anchored a unit that remains among the league’s deepest at the position.
Herbig burst onto the scene with a breakout 2025 campaign, posting a career-high 7.5 sacks, 13 tackles for loss, and 18 quarterback hits. That volume underscores why Pittsburgh is exploring an extension now, in hopes of locking in his prime alongside Highsmith.
If the Steelers can align on terms with Herbig while maintaining Highsmith’s security, they could preserve a formidable edge-rush duo well beyond 2026. The ultimate outcome will depend on Herbig’s decision to sign now or test the market next year and the Steelers’ willingness to meet the associated price tag.
In sum, Pittsburgh’s pursuit of both Herbig and Highsmith reflects a broader strategy to sustain one of the league’s most versatile and productive edge-rush groups. The club’s offseason moves will determine whether this elite unit remains intact for years to come.
