McGuinness argues Downs has been consistently strong across three college seasons, posting an 85.0-plus PFF grade each year and drawing comparisons to prior top safeties drafted high, such as Kyle Hamilton. While positional value can influence draft order, Downs’ production and final-year impact have solidified him as a candidate to go early in the top 10.
A closer look at Downs shows a player with advanced football IQ, quick pre-snap instincts, and reliable tackling in open space. ESPN’s Mel Kiper Jr. ranks Downs as the No. 6 overall prospect and the top defensive back in the 2026 class, underscoring his long-term potential to lead a secondary. In 2025, Downs totaled 68 tackles, 2 forced fumbles, and 2 interceptions for Ohio State.
For the Jets, Downs represents a potential anchor at the safety position, a notable area of concern after the 2025 season saw the defense struggle, including a league-worst tally of zero interceptions by the entire unit. New York ranked 31st in points allowed per game (29.6) and has indicated a need for a playmaking presence in the secondary and at the backend of the defense.
Beyond Downs, the Jets still face other defensive needs, such as adding a pass rusher. If safety is prioritized in the draft, the team could also explore free-agent options this offseason to bolster the back end while continuing to address edge pressure in the later rounds or with targeted acquisitions.
Overall, Downs’ strong collegiate résumé and high regard across NFL draft circles position him as a strategic fit for a Jets defense seeking a disruptive, reliable starter at safety. If New York commits to a top-10 pick on Downs, it would mark a significant shift toward stabilizing the back end as part of a broader defensive overhaul.
