Bleacher Report’s Tim Kelly highlighted both Realmuto and García as possible bust candidates for 2026. Realmuto, a three-time All-Star, posted a .275/.315/.384 line with 12 homers and 52 RBIs in 2025, and his defensive runs saved dipped to minus-2, a notable decline from his Gold Glove performance in 2022. Some incentives, such as a $1 million Silver Slugger clause, appear ambitious given his recent trajectory. Kelly notes Realmuto’s heavy workload, catching over 1,100 innings at age 34, raising concerns about sustainability.
García, who peaked with a strong 2021-23 run but has shown substantial offensive decline since, is viewed primarily for his defense in right field. He has posted a .675 OPS across the last two seasons, making the Phillies’ offseason addition a potential risk if his bat does not rebound alongside his defense.
The Phillies also endured other offseason moves, including the loss of left-handed pitcher Ranger Suárez to the Boston Red Sox and the decision to part with outfielder Nick Castellanos. While re-signing Schwarber keeps the lineup strong, missing out on Bo Bichette to the Mets and ongoing internal questions surrounding Harper-era management have created a sense of uncertainty entering spring training. If Realmuto and García fail to meet expectations, Philadelphia’s command of the NL East could face added scrutiny as the season approaches.
