Running back Kenneth Gainwell, acquired from Philadelphia, has thrived in Pittsburgh, posting 114 carries for 537 yards and five touchdowns in 2025. At 26, he’s entering his prime, frequently pairing with Jaylen Warren to form a productive duo that totaled 11 rushing scores. Gainwell’s bargain $1.79 million deal expires mid-March, making his future with the Steelers a key off-field storyline.
McCarthy’s arrival could be the catalyst for continued backfield success, given his track record of elevating running games in Dallas, including Rico Dowdle’s 1,000-yard season and Tony Pollard’s Pro Bowl recognition. Pittsburgh’s front office is likely to keep Gainwell, who thrived in free agency, as a contributor under a new coaching regime.
The other major decision centers on tight end Pat Freiermuth, one of the Steelers’ highest-paid pass catchers. After a down 2025, Freiermuth posted 41 receptions for 486 yards and four touchdowns, a notable drop from 2024. Analysts have begun to explore a potential exit strategy, given his $9.1 million cap hit in 2026 and questions about fit alongside Rodgers.
Freiermuth’s on-field potential remains evident, evidenced by his Week 7 explosion against Cincinnati (111 yards, two touchdowns) and a late-game 68-yard connection with Rodgers that kept Pittsburgh competitive. Still, he was frequently out-snapped by Darnell Washington, raising questions about him as the central long-term target in the passing game under McCarthy.
With McCarthy at the helm, the Steelers must decide whether to build around Freiermuth’s upside or consider trade possibilities to maximize value. The decision will significantly shape Pittsburgh’s offensive strategy and cap structure as the team plans for 2026.
