Tarver represents continuity, having worked under Jim Schwartz for three seasons and previously serving as Raiders defensive coordinator from 2012-14, a stint that ended with a challenging ranking for the unit. Staying with Tarver could send a message of stability to players and staff amid the transition.
Undlin, a former Jaguars assistant, is noted for a prior connection with Browns head coach Todd Monken and has experience alongside Schwartz on the Eagles’ staff (2016-19). His familiarity with Monken’s system could facilitate a smoother handoff if selected.
Rutenberg is the dark horse of the group, bringing a fresh perspective as Falcons’ passing game coordinator and previously Jets linebackers coach (2021-24). He has no overt ties to the Browns or Monken, which could be viewed as a move toward new ideas.
Monken has indicated he can run Schwartz’s “wide nine” defense without Schwartz himself, stressing that player performance drives the unit’s success. Nonetheless, the Browns’ choice will influence how the defense is led and how players respond to leadership changes.
Jim Schwartz helped elevate individual players during his tenure, including Maliek Collins, Alex Wright, Devin Bush, and Myles Garrett, who credited Schwartz with improving his development. The incoming coordinator will need to sustain those gains while aligning with Monken’s broader defensive vision.
