A recent ESPN proposal from Bill Barnwell suggests the Buffalo Bills could trade Keon Coleman, the 2024 second-round pick, to the Jacksonville Jaguars in exchange for Brian Thomas Jr. and a 2026 sixth-rounder. Barnwell argues Coleman’s production and the team’s public criticism of the pick complicate his long-term fit in Buffalo, making a move appealing if it yields a higher-impact target for Josh Allen.
Coleman has posted 67 receptions for 960 yards and eight touchdowns across two Bills seasons, including 38 receptions for 404 yards and four TDs in 2025. His playoff showing—a combined two catches for 46 yards and a TD in the losses to Jacksonville and Denver—has amplified questions about his role and development with Buffalo.
Barnwell contends the Bills need an athletic “X” receiver who can separate in man coverage and contribute at all three levels. He notes ownership’s unfavorable remarks about the 2024 pick at the end-of-year press conference as a potential barrier to Coleman’s long-term tenure in Buffalo.
The Jaguars, according to Barnwell, could part with Brian Thomas Jr. after a down sophomore season, trading him alongside a 2026 first-round pick (projected) to replenish their missing 2026 first-round selection. Thomas, who burst onto the scene with a strong rookie year but regressed in 2025 under head coach Liam Coen, could benefit from a fresh system with Joe Brady in Buffalo.
Barnwell argues that if Thomas regains his form, he could immediately slot in as Buffalo’s No. 1 receiver, while his affordable contract ($2.1M in 2026, $2.8M in 2027) would offer the Bills durable cost control during a tight cap period. He also notes that Jacksonville’s altered draft capital and need for a high-impact target could influence a deal that benefits both teams.
The proposal highlights broader questions for Buffalo: whether Coleman can prove his ceiling in a revamped offense, and whether moving for a proven (or potentially resurging) playmaker like Thomas would yield a better short- and long-term return. As the 2026 offseason approaches, this trade scenario remains a talking point in NFL front-office discussions.
