In his own words, Carr stated: “Would I come back? The answer is obviously yes… I would have to be healthy, and I’d want a chance to win a Super Bowl.” His brother David added, “I know you’re healthy,” underscoring the health prerequisite Carr has repeatedly cited.
A snapshot of the current landscape shows the Jets’ Super Bowl odds are not favorable. DraftKings Sportsbook lists the Jets at 180-1 to win next season, tied with the Las Vegas Raiders for the second-worst mark; only the Miami Dolphins and Arizona Cardinals are worse at 200-1, per ESPN.
The idea of Carr in New York isn’t entirely new. In 2023, the Jets pursued him aggressively, hosting meetings at the NFL combine and around New Jersey. Dianna Russini, then reporting for ESPN, described a pitch that sold Carr on a pathway to a championship and even the possibility of Hall of Fame consideration if he joined the Jets.
Since that offseason, the Jets have undergone front-office and coach-teaching changes, and the roster has evolved. While Carr’s recollection of those “good times” could leave the door ajar for renewed interest, there is currently no confirmation of fresh talks, and the degree to which the Jets remain a viable long-term option for him remains uncertain.
Social media reactions to Carr’s comments have been mixed, with some analysts suggesting the Jets might be ruled out, while others imply Carr could still be high on the possibility. Overall, the latest remarks keep the Jets-Carr conversation in play, even as odds and roster realities continue to shift.
