LaFleur arrives with a reputation as an up-and-coming offensive mind, having worked under Kyle Shanahan and Sean McVay. That pedigree has fueled optimism among some in Arizona that he could help unlock a rebuilding roster.
However, the bottom-tier placement in the poll underscores concerns about fit and organizational stability rather than coaching ability. A team executive emphasized that success hinges on how well the coach aligns with the personnel side and the resources available to execute a plan.
The Athletic’s Jeff Howe noted the “unknowns” surrounding both LaFleur and Monken, highlighting that they’re first-time NFL head coaches stepping into franchises that have struggled to establish stability. The lack of a proven track record in the current organizational context contributed to the cautious approach among voters.
The Cardinals entered the cycle with perhaps the weakest opening, given their ongoing rebuild and a history of playoff droughts. The future of quarterback Kyler Murray remains a central question, and any coaching hire will need a clear succession and roster plan in lockstep with general manager Monti Ossenfort.
Ultimately, LaFleur’s success will depend on long-term alignment between the coaching staff and front office, plus a coherent roster strategy. While the hire carries upside, early expectations for an immediate turnaround are tempered by the team’s instability and uncertain quarterback situation.
