In 2025, Buffalo produced one of the NFL’s most productive rushing attacks, with Cook shouldering the majority of the workload as the team moved away from a backfield-by-committee approach.
Johnson’s role as a reliable third-down back was meaningful, but with Cook potentially becoming a true three-down option, some see Johnson as a luxury the Bills could now trim to boost cap savings. Ray Davis has also shown enough in limited duty to handle third-down duties if needed.
A crucial factor in the decision is the financials: cutting Johnson would save about $2.455 million in cap space before other moves are accounted for, a consideration teams weigh alongside the need to preserve a versatile backfield.
Ray Davis carved out a niche as a kick returner, earning All-Pro honors and providing a valuable change of pace when used sparingly. The Bills could choose to keep the trio intact into 2026, relying on Davis’s versatility and Cook’s durability, with Johnson providing additional depth.
Analysts have floated different paths: some suggest restructuring contracts and making a calculated cut to free space, potentially drafting a third back on a rookie deal to pair with Cook and Davis. Others emphasize the trio’s complementary value, noting Johnson’s blocking and matchup potential alongside Cook and Davis. The Bills’ approach will hinge on balancing cap relief with backfield versatility as they shape 2026.
