Myers accounted for all of Seattle’s scoring through the first three quarters, delivering a 12-0 lead before the fourth period. His five successful attempts became the defining mark of the Seahawks’ offensive performance on the night.
The Super Bowl MVP went to a teammate, prompting debate among fans and pundits about whether Myers’ historic kicking night deserved the honor. The question intensified after his record-setting showing in a victorious effort.
Fans and analysts weighed in publicly, with figures like former NFL punter-turned-commentator Pat McAfee arguing that Myers should be recognized as MVP for the kicking performance alone.
NFL MVP voting combines a fan component (20%) with a media panel of 16 members (80%), with ballots typically submitted around the two-minute warning. This structure means a strong performance can be overshadowed by the voting mix.
Controversy arose because Myers wasn’t listed among the MVP candidates on the NFL’s site, which highlighted other players, and because the panel can select from either team and adjust ballots if late plays influence the game.
The episode has reignited discussion about the MVP process and whether a kicker’s record-setting night should command consideration for one of the league’s most prestigious individual honors.
