Nagy is described as an experienced offensive mind who has worked with top players across the NFL, and his addition signals a formal alignment of Harbaugh’s leadership with an established play-caller.
The hire comes after the Giants’ search featured several candidates. Todd Monken was reported as the No. 1 target, with Harbaugh reportedly wanting to bring his Ravens OC to New York before Harbaugh left for the Cleveland Browns head coaching job. SNY insider Connor Hughes noted that the Giants’ second-choice option, Charlie Weis Jr., also declined the extension and chose to remain in college football.
Weis Jr. is the Ole Miss alumnus who served as LSU’s offensive coordinator, working with Jaxson Dart during his time with the Rebels. Dart has spoken highly of Weis, highlighting the strong bond they developed and the impact Weis had on Dart’s progression as a passer.
Weis ultimately did not leave LSU, choosing to follow Lane Kiffin to the Tigers after Ole Miss’ run to the CFP semifinals. That decision left Nagy as the path forward for New York, with Hughes indicating there were competing preferences that ultimately did not materialize.
Giants fans have expressed mixed reactions to Nagy’s hire, with some skepticism about his offensive pedigree. Hughes added that Harbaugh wouldn’t hesitate to make another move in 2027 if Nagy’s approach doesn’t meet expectations.
Overall, the Giants proceed with Nagy as offensive coordinator under Harbaugh, acknowledging that the club explored multiple options and faced fan skepticism while signaling a willingness to reassess the position if needed.
