The proposed deal centers on a need that has loomed over Washington for years: a proven pass rusher to give the defense a clear advantage. With a subpar 2025 in the rearview, and veteran Von Miller aging toward 37, Washington may prioritize a younger, under-contract solution who can impact immediate games and remain part of the long-term plan.
Highsmith brings a track record: 45 sacks across six seasons, plus coverage versatility. Bailey notes Highsmith has not allowed a touchdown on 55 targets (34 completions) and is adept at driving downhill in the run game, using his speed and length to disrupt plays from the edge.
A trade for Highsmith could also shift Washington’s draft strategy and rotation upfront. Bailey argues such a move would free up opportunities for Nick Herbig to start and sign an extension, while also opening reps for Jack Sawyer. It would let defensive coordinator Daronte Lee lean into his back-end focus while integrating a proven edge rusher into the front seven.
The rationale for Pittsburgh rests on broader roster-building goals. Bailey points out the Steelers own top-100 picks and may prioritize accumulating more draft capital through 2027 to position themselves for a potential franchise quarterback—potentially reducing the urgency to keep Highsmith if a favorable offer comes.
If the price remains as Bailey projects, Washington would land a near-term difference-maker at a cost that many compare favorably to the market for elite edge players, while gaining long-term flexibility. Still, the move hinges on whether Pittsburgh views Highsmith as expendable for the right combination of picks and conditionally valued assets.
Overall, the proposal presents a credible, evaluated path for Washington to upgrade the pass rush without sacrificing the breadth of their future draft flexibility. Whether the Commanders pursue it depends on how Pittsburgh values the asset and whether Washington deems the upgrade worth the short- and long-term cost.
