Rodgers signed a one-year deal to join the Steelers for 2025 and tempered expectations about a longer run, though he also left room for a potential return. He produced solid numbers for his age, going 10-6 as a starter with 3,322 passing yards, 24 touchdowns and seven interceptions, while signaling that 2025 could be his final season.
McCarthy has been explicit in backing Rodgers since returning to the Steelers’ sideline. During his WDVE interview, and again in his introductory press conference, he stated that he doesn’t see why Rodgers wouldn’t return, reflecting their long-standing rapport from 13 years coaching Rodgers with the Green Bay Packers.
The dynamic between McCarthy and Rodgers has been explored beyond their recent reunification. Ian O’Connor, in discussing a new book, reiterated that their relationship is stronger now than it was in Green Bay, noting that while they batted heads at times, their collaboration yielded continued success for Rodgers.
As with last season, McCarthy appears to be employing a gradual approach, allowing Rodgers to take his time to decide. That strategy, similar to Mike Tomlin’s handling of the Steelers’ quarterback situation, ensures ongoing speculation in the spring while a definitive answer remains pending.
If Rodgers does return, Pittsburgh would aim to stabilize a Week 1 quarterback situation that has shifted in each of the past four seasons. If not, the Steelers’ next steps remain uncertain, with McCarthy’s public backing creating a clear but contingent path forward for 2026.
