The 32-year-old wideout remains productive, even as Tampa Bay’s recent struggles complicate the picture. Pro Football Focus notes Evans’ 2025 injuries derailed his season, but his 2024 finish was strong (an 89.0 PFF grade, fourth among receivers), and his efficiency—2.21 yards per route run over the past two seasons—rates among the league’s best. With Buffalo lacking depth at outside receiver and limited vertical stretch, Evans would provide a meaningful upgrade for Josh Allen’s passing game.
Injuries have become Evans’ most persistent issue of late. He missed three games with a hamstring in 2024 and sat out nine in 2025 due to a hamstring and a broken collarbone. Over his previous 11 seasons, he had missed 13 games overall, never more than two in a single year before 2024.
Despite the durability concerns, Evans is chasing more than numbers. He tied Jerry Rice by logging his 11th consecutive 1,000-yard receiving season in 2024 and remained in pursuit of a potential Hall of Fame résumé as he neared the end of his current contract.
With a two-year, $52 million deal now behind him in Tampa Bay, Evans could explore the open market as a proven veteran presence who could immediately impact a contender. A move to Buffalo would align with a win-now mindset for the Bills, potentially changing the balance of their offense.
Fan sentiment in Tampa Bay underscores the potential heartbreak if Evans leaves. A prominent post from a local podcaster captured the mood, highlighting how crucial his presence has been for Buccaneers supporters and how devastating his departure would feel.
Overall, the scenario remains fluid: Evans could pursue another championship with Buffalo or stay in Tampa while assessing his options. PFF’s evaluation highlights the Bills’ need for outside receiving depth and vertical threat ability, painting a realistic path for Evans to pursue a title with a new team.
